Car Rentals Rip-offs: 6 Things to Watch For

On a recent trip to New York, I needed to rent a car for one day. The goal was to pick it up at JFK airport and return it the next day to a nearby town about 15 minutes away.

I shopped several rental car sites but ultimately chose Enterprise. While their prices weren’t great ($62.50 for a sub-compact), they were competitive. And most importantly, I knew they had an office in the nearby town where I needed to leave the car.

There was no way to indicate online that I wanted to return the car to a location other than JFK. But rather than do the smart thing – call Enterprise and ask them if there would be an extra fee – I did the dumb thing. I said to myself, “I’m sure there’s going to be a fee for not returning the car to the airport, but how much could it be?”

Answer? $75. Which was more than it cost to rent the car.

This is something I learned only after stepping up to the Enterprise counter at JFK. I did manage to talk the rental agent down to $50, but there’s still no excuse for putting myself in this position, especially considering my experience with this exact type of story.

The reason I was renting a car was to drive to Yonkers, NY, to attend a conference at Consumer Reports. Ironically, at about the same time I was leaving JFK in my Nissan Cube, Consumer Reports was issuing a press release titled CR Warns Against Rental Car Gimmicks.

While their press release didn’t mention what happened to me, it did warn against some other interesting rental car fees to watch for…

Treat a rental car like a hotel mini bar: Don’t take any goodies without knowing the price. This includes GPS navigation, satellite radio, and child safety seats. One Consumer Reports reader was charged $9.50 for $2 worth of tolls after he used an EZ-Pass toll payment transponder he found inside his Hertz rental.

Other things they warned about…

Damage waiver: Even though you know you’re already covered by your car insurance policy, rental agents pushing their company’s damage waiver coverage will sound so convincing that you’ll feel like you’re risking it all for refusing their extra coverage. Fall for it, and according to Consumer reports, you could end up shelling out an extra $60 to $250 a week.

Damage claims: Consumer Reports says one of their readers was charged $304 for “damage” to a rental car after dropping it off when the place was closed. Their advice: Always pay by credit card so you an dispute inaccurate charges. My additional advice? Use your phone’s camera to take pictures of any scratches on the car before you rent it, and to document its condition when you return it.

Fill it up: This is old news. Everyone knows by now that if you’re supposed to bring it back full and you fail to do so, the rental car company will mark up the gas price you’ll pay. What you may not know, however, is just how much they’re marking it up these days: according to CR, up to $8 per gallon.

Then there’s the other side of the same coin: When I rented my car, Enterprise offered to charge me less than the going price for gas. The catch? I had to buy the whole tank’s worth. While I didn’t know exactly how many miles I’d be driving, or what kind of mileage the car would get, I declined. Good decision – when I filled up the car prior to returning it, I found my entire trip from JFK to Yonkers and back took less than 4 gallons.

Stick with the cheapest cars: In days past, rental car companies would often give free upgrades. Now that cars are in shorter supply, this is less common. While still worth asking for, if you can’t get a free upgrade, don’t get talked into paying for one. Smaller cars are typically easier to drive and park, use less gas, and if – God forbid – something uninsured does happen, cost less to replace.

For more ways to save on rental cars, check out Rental Cars: 5 Tips for a Better Deal.

Sign up for our free newsletter

Like this article? Sign up for our newsletter and we'll send you a regular digest of our newest stories, full of money saving tips and advice, free! We'll also email you a PDF of Stacy Johnson's "205 Ways to Save Money" as soon as you've subscribed. It's full of great tips that'll help you save a ton of extra cash. It doesn't cost a dime, so why wait? Click here to sign up now.

Check out our hottest deals!

We're always adding new deals and coupons that'll save you big bucks. See the deals to the right and hundreds more in our Deals section.

Click here to explore 1,217 more deals!

Comments & discussion

We welcome your opinions, but let’s keep it civil. Like many businesses, we reserve the right to refuse service to anyone. In our case, that means those who communicate by name-calling, racism, using words designed to hurt others or generally acting like an uninformed bully. Also, comments that include links to email addresses or commercial websites typically aren't posted. This isn't a place to advertise your business.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_P5TUDDH3ZVKETH54YXXA54FWFE VANESSA

    Great article.  I have been renting cars for the past few months because of my travel schedule.  I always decline the lower priced gas.  I had no idea the catch was that you have to buy a full tanks worth.  What a racket!

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_7UITVJTXVSSNF22KQVEIHYK2B4 Joe

    Rental cars are the worst offender. We are here to generate revenue for companies but these business pratice are simply outrageous. Is there any great rental cars or companies in America anymore?

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_UZ5L5KTLERBAG3QZHT3I42MCFI abby

    I was charged $75 for a cleaning fee by Hertz. They rented me the vehicle dirty and said just bring it back with a
    full tank of gas. I did what they said and returned the vehicle. They inspected it and charged me exactly what I
    expected and gave me a reciept. About a week later I got another charge on my credit card for $75. I didn’t realize it till about three weeks later and I called Hertz. The agent told me it was a cleaning fee which was in the contract

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_ARSEKDGZKZVN4HRJRZGU2MZEKM racam

    This article is somewhat irresponsible and biased.  The things he talks about as rip offs or scams are not necessarily either if used appropriately.  One way fees get charged because in many cases, the car belongs to the location that rented it. The drop location may not have any renters looking to return to that location which means the original location will have to pay someone to bring it back.  Same thing for fuel mark up.  It seems high, and probably is, but you’re not just paying for the fuel, you’re paying for someone to put the fuel in the car. Time is Money. If you spend a little time to fill the car yourself, you’ll save $$. Get someone else to do it, pay them. LDW is worth it if the cost is less than your deductible on your policy. Also, do you really want a claim going against your insurance for a car you will never drive again? Is it worth paying your deductible and having your premium go up? Paying for an upgrade can also be worth it if travel plans have changed or the cost to move up is cheap. It’s best to book the class that meets your minimum requirements. You may still get the free upgrade and if not, the price to go up probably isn’t that bad.  Never book below your comfort level, that’s when you end up paying more than you should.  Research is always your best weapon.