Does Bargain Toothpaste Work as Well?

By on

Visits to the dentist can wreak havoc on your wallet, especially if you stop in for anything beyond routine care.

Dental cleanings and exams are recommended twice a year, so it’s up to you to perform routine maintenance between visits. But what works best when you’re selecting toothpaste — the name brand with tartar control, whitening, or other bells and whistles, or a simple generic or store brand?

Tempted to go the generic route to give your wallet a break? In the video below, Money Talks News founder Stacy Johnson discusses what you should consider when buying bargain toothpaste. Take a look and meet me on the other side for additional money-saving tips.

Locate the ADA’s seal of approval

The first thing to look for when evaluating the quality of a generic toothpaste is the seal of approval from the American Dental Association. It provides you with “assurance that the product has been objectively evaluated for safety and effectiveness by an independent body of scientific experts, the ADA Council on Scientific Affairs,” the ADA’s website says. 

Examine ingredients

You should take things a step further and compare the active ingredients in the cheaper product you are considering with that of a brand-name product to see if the two are similar.

Says Livestrong:

The American Dental Association claims that a good toothpaste first and foremost should have fluoride as an ingredient. Fluoride has been shown in studies to be effective at reducing cavities by 40 percent.

It does so by strengthening the enamel of your teeth each time it is applied to the surface via your toothbrush. Fluoride also facilitates the removal of plaque and helps hedge against the risk of gum disease and tooth decay. All ADA-approved toothpastes contain this ingredient.

Other beneficial ingredients to look for, suggests the ADA, include:

  • Zinc citrate, pyrophosphates or triclosan to help reduce the accumulation of plaque or tartar.
  • Strontium chloride or potassium nitrate to diminish sensitivity.
  • Stannous fluoride and triclosan to hedge against the risk of gum inflammation.

Ask your dentist for recommendations

Once you’ve checked the label for active ingredients, you may want to speak with your dentist about the product you’re considering. Also, inquire about low-cost alternatives that are just as effective.

You may find that your dentist doesn’t necessarily prefer one brand over the other, as long as your toothpaste has that all-important fluoride and an ingredient like zinc citrate that fights tartar buildup. DailyFinance notes:

Four out of five dentists say brand doesn’t matter, so anything beyond those two ingredients is likely increasing the retail price of your toothpaste. As a quick rule of thumb, avoid special features or additives that sound fancy. There’s no reason to pay more when many product[s] contain [the] same or similar active ingredients.

Other ways to save

There are other ways to save on the cost of toothpaste without reducing the quality of care you’ve giving your teeth (which, if you really care about your teeth and gums, includes the daily use of floss).

  • Use as recommended. Take a look at the tube and you will find that it instructs children to use a pea-sized amount each time they brush. Guess what? Suzette Standring wrote on The Huffington Post that that’s enough for adults as well. Less is definitely more — saving you money while preserving the surface of your teeth.
  • Coupon. Next time you’re at the dentist office, ask about whether coupons are available for patients. Also, go online or scan the newspaper to clip coupons from the manufacturer when they are available. In the past, I’ve purchased brand-name tubes for pennies on the dollar.
  • Squeeze from the bottom. Roll the tube from the bottom to the top and you’ll be surprised at how much you can actually retrieve.
  • Whip out the scissors. Down to the last drop? Cut the tube open with a pair of scissors to access the remaining paste.

Too lazy to do the legwork? Take a look at the comprehensive list of toothpastes that have been accepted by the ADA. You will find that multimillion-dollar marketing campaigns and hefty price tags don’t necessarily equate to higher-quality products.

What’s your experience with bargain toothpaste? Let us know in the comments below or on our Facebook page.

Sign up for our free newsletter

Like this article? Sign up for our newsletter and we'll send you a regular digest of our newest stories, full of money saving tips and advice, free! We'll also email you a PDF of Stacy Johnson's "205 Ways to Save Money" as soon as you've subscribed. It's full of great tips that'll help you save a ton of extra cash. It doesn't cost a dime, so why wait? Click here to sign up now.

Check out our hottest deals!

We're always adding new deals and coupons that'll save you big bucks. See the deals to the right and hundreds more in our Deals section.

Click here to explore 1,095 more deals!

Comments & discussion

We welcome your opinions, but let’s keep it civil. Like many businesses, we reserve the right to refuse service to anyone. In our case, that means those who communicate by name-calling, racism, using words designed to hurt others or generally acting like an uninformed bully. Also, comments that include links to email addresses or commercial websites typically aren't posted. This isn't a place to advertise your business.

  • ModernMode

    Triclosan has been in the news recently for having adverse health effects. Its also used in antibacterial soaps. Many manufacturers are removing it from their products.

    • marketfog

      The jury is still out on Triclosan, but it appears that it is not good for you. How does it get into the body? Triclosan is absorbed through the tissues lining the mouth, and through the skin.

  • I.Popoff

    I haven’t used toothpaste in years and haven’t had any cavities either.

    • thejgal

      @I.Popoff, May I ask what do you use? Curious. I once meet a person who only used baking soda and in her nineties, she still had all her own teeth.

      • I.Popoff

        I usually brush twice a day with plain water and floss in the shower once a day. Before bed I rinse with Equate Mouth Rinse or peroxide. I won’t say I’ve never had any cavities, but since I stopped using toothpaste several years ago my dental exams are routine with no plaque concerns.

  • Robert

    This article is yet another reason the ADA has become pretty much irrelevant. Good rule to follow: if it’s a chemical whose name you can’t pronounce, don’t put it in your mouth. Even if you’re going to rinse it out. Especially if it has fluoride in it. Fluoride is a poison, the effects of which are just now coming to light (given 50 some years of use in toothpastes and having it added to water supplies). IMHO, if you want fluoride and think it does you any good, go right ahead and add it to your diet. Just don’t put it in the water and force it on everybody. In the meantime, if you want to prevent cavities, try not gorging yourself with sugar. I really expected better from MoneyTalksNews. Makes me question other stuff they put out.

  • Jcatz4

    @Gars – my guess is that if the “bargain toothpaste” is approved by the ADA and has the recommended ingredients, then it probably works as well as name brand toothpaste. I haven’t had to buy “bargain toothpaste”. The name brand toothpastes that I buy are usually always bargains because I use coupons and look for the best price. There have been many times where the tubes of toothpaste have ended up being “free” or almost free. My local Rite Aid (a drug store chain here in the Phila./SJersey area) has had many, many great deals on brand name toothpastes.

  • Y2KJillian

    What about brand-name toothpaste at Dollar stores? I never pay more than $1 for a tube. And–they actually tell you how much to use? I never knew. We had a “discussion” just this AM about how much was appropriate. Now we know.

  • SANHEDRIN

    I used the Sensodyne brand, but have used Crest and the whole lot…..one of their brands concentrate on acids, enamel, as well as fluoride..it is $5 a small tube, but I can afford it, some pay $4,300 annually for 2 packs of cigarettes a day……they never admit it…a $5 tube lasts me a month