Fly or Drive? 9 Factors to Consider

By on

Planning a trip to enjoy the autumn foliage or go wine-tasting? According to a recent TripAdvisor survey, 86 percent of travelers are planning a leisure trip this fall, and those are the top activities.

For those who traveled on Labor Day, 60 percent expected to drive, and 34 percent planned to fly. (Guess the other 6 percent were either taking trains or boats.) But how often is driving a better option than flying?

In the video below, Money Talks News reporter Jim Robinson takes a look at that question, using a trip calculator to weigh the costs and benefits. Check it out, and then read on for more.

Here’s the tool Jim used: BeFrugal’s fly or drive calculator. Plug in some travel dates, locations, the number of people going, and some other optional info to get a side-by-side comparison. Regardless of how the money shakes out, though, Jim’s right – both modes have their pros and cons. Here are a few things to consider before you decide…

  1. Packing. Fly, and you’re looking at baggage fees in the realm of $20 per bag, per person, each way. This could easily cost a family of four $160. If you drive, there are no extra fees and you can stuff whatever you want in the car. But depending on the vehicle, there may not be much space for everyone’s luggage.
  2. Pace. Flights require you to arrive by a certain time so they can make you stand in a long line and then sit in the takeoff queue. Plus there are storm delays and waiting at baggage claim – but the farther you have to go, the more time you save. And at least there’s no traffic in the sky. Drive and you’ll face lots of it, but your travel time is otherwise only restricted by your own endurance. (And maybe speed limits.)
  3. Scenery. On a road trip, every seat’s a window seat, and you can stop for a closer look whenever you want. In the air, you’re stuck with the in-flight movie (if you get one) or the snoring guy in the next seat.
  4. Distance. Where long distance is a factor, so are overnight accommodations. Unless you plan to sleep in your car or drive all night – not the safest idea – you have to add motel costs to the total price, and food costs stack up too.
  5. Numbers. The biggest cost factor is how many people are traveling with you. Costs multiply per person on a flight, while driving allows you to pool gas money.
  6. Safety. According to the Smithsonian Institution, planes are far safer than cars: “More people die in auto accidents in three months in the United States than have lost their lives in the entire history of commercial flight.”
  7. Multitasking. Driving duty leaves you with little time to relax or get work done so you can enjoy time off at your destination. Take a plane and you can sit on your laptop or smartphone – maybe with in-flight Wi-Fi.
  8. Comfort. Sitting in a car for hours is no fun, but at least you can get out and stretch. That’s impossible while crammed in a plane, and you may have to jostle others just to reach the bathroom.
  9. Destination travel. Flying may leave you without a free ride from the airport, and may mean public transportation or cabs to get around. Bringing your own vehicle can save on that expense.

Bottom line? The choice between flying and driving isn’t always obvious. If you weigh the benefits and plug some numbers into a flight calculator, you might be surprised. If you are going to fly, take some advice from Money Talks News travel expert Jason Steele – he’s a licensed pilot who knows all the tricks, from flying business class cheap to the best frequent flier programs and maximizing bonus miles.

Sign up for our free newsletter

Like this article? Sign up for our newsletter and we'll send you a regular digest of our newest stories, full of money saving tips and advice, free! We'll also email you a PDF of Stacy Johnson's "205 Ways to Save Money" as soon as you've subscribed. It's full of great tips that'll help you save a ton of extra cash. It doesn't cost a dime, so why wait? Click here to sign up now.

Check out our hottest deals!

We're always adding new deals and coupons that'll save you big bucks. See the deals to the right and hundreds more in our Deals section.

Click here to explore 1,287 more deals!

Comments & discussion

We welcome your opinions, but let’s keep it civil. Like many businesses, we reserve the right to refuse service to anyone. In our case, that means those who communicate by name-calling, racism, using words designed to hurt others or generally acting like an uninformed bully. Also, comments that include links to email addresses or commercial websites typically aren't posted. This isn't a place to advertise your business.

  • Nancy Moreau

    Poorly done conclusion in your video. I used the site you mentioned and the numbers swing dramatically the other way when you consider things like a rental car when you arrive by Plane versus driving your own vehicle. My numbers came out on a trip that I flew for several years and now drive regualrly to be $1560.52 by air versus $337.66 for driving with a total time difference of 6 hours less time for flying versus driving. I think you should have mentioned in your video what your assumptions were as obviously you must not have had transportation for the days you were going to stay at your destination and obviously the number of days you are staying somehwere play into the cost of a rental as well as airport parking. Nowhere in the software to understnad total cost was there a place for delays while sitting on the tarmack which is a regular occurance if you fly anywhere in NY or flight delays even for boarding. Those in my situation turned a 1.5 hour flight into 8-9 hour flight if you inlude those type of typical delays. If you travel with more then one person the numbers for flying increase as well. So speaking only for myslef I found the conclusion in the video to be misleading when considering all the other elements that impact cost.and time comparisons. If you are into the green thing the carbon footprint is also much greater for flying in my instance.Overall flying comes nowhere close to the savings that occur driving The software you identified shows what my expense accounts have shown for the last four years from real data