Totaled in Kansas, Not in Colorado

By on

This post comes from Mark Vallet at partner site CarInsurance.com.

Will your car go to the body shop or the scrap heap? It depends on where you live and who your insurance company is.

Legally, insurers are required to declare a car totaled and apply for a salvage title once damage reaches a certain point under your state’s law. For example, a car with damage totaling 50 percent of its value is totaled in Iowa but considered repairable in nearby Missouri, where the threshold is 80 percent.

Twenty-eight states set total-loss thresholds, which are calculated by dividing the cost of the repairs by the pre-accident cash value of the car. Other states use a different total-loss formula: If the cost of repairs plus the scrap value of the wreckage is greater than the pre-accident value of the car, it’s totaled.

Yet insurers frequently total cars with damage that doesn’t reach these thresholds.

So what can you expect after your next accident?

Why is my car a total loss?

Insurers are totaling more vehicles than ever. According to claims expert CCC Information Services, in 2000 roughly 9 percent of all vehicles that came in for an appraisal were totaled. By 2012 that number was up to 14 percent.

You may think the damage to your vehicle is minimal, but your insurer is looking at it with different eyes.

Your insurance company doesn’t care about your fond memories, sentimental attachment, or the fact that you might not be able to afford a new car. It’s all business: The bottom line is that it is going to take the cheapest option.

From our Solutions Center: How to quickly shop insurance

The criteria for making a decision on totaling a vehicle is different for every insurer and in many cases it is dictated by state law, but the basic formula is usually the same. If repair costs reach a certain threshold of the actual cash value (ACV) of the car, say goodbye to your ride.

Says lawyer Thomas Simeone with Simeone & Miller, “Legally, the most an insurance company is liable for is the actual cash value of the vehicle at the time of the accident. Their decision will be based on whether it is cheaper to repair the car back to that condition or simply write you a check and total the vehicle.”

The total-loss process explained

An appraiser will examine the car and calculate not only the cost of repairs but also your car’s pre-accident cash value, considering make, model, year, options, mileage and condition.

While total-loss thresholds may be mandated by state law, they rarely come into play. Even though insurers are required to total the cars that are over these thresholds, they can and do total many vehicles that are under the threshold.

“Insurance carriers that operate in multiple states have an internal mechanism for assessing total-loss levels so as to be consistent regardless of where the vehicle is located,” says Tony Rached of Total Loss Appraisals in Alpharetta, Ga.

That may be why total-loss thresholds seem to have little bearing on the actual number of total-loss claims in a state. The Midwest has some of the lowest thresholds, which should lead to a high number of total-loss claims, but according to CCC Information Services, the region has the second-lowest percentage of total-loss claims at 13 percent.

What you can do?

Total-loss claims are often frustrating. This is especially true when it comes to determining value for your vehicle. Pete Moraga with the Insurance Information Network of California offers a few tips for making the process more bearable:

  • Keep in mind that a “one size fits all” valuation never works.
  • If the total loss is not your fault, you should be compensated for a rental car.
  • Be patient, as some of these types of claims may be complicated.
  • Start shopping for a new car as soon as possible; rental car coverage is usually good for only 30 days.

If you just love your car and don’t want to see it junked, or you are unhappy with the settlement amount, you can:

Buy it back. If you really want to keep your car, most insurers will oblige. Your insurance company will write a check for the actual cash value of the vehicle minus your deductible as well as the salvage value.

While you still have your car, it is now up to you to repair it. In addition, the car now has a salvage title attached to it, which can make it more difficult to insure, even if it has been repaired.

Challenge the appraisal. If you are unhappy with their number, challenge it. While most appraisers will bump their offer up $500 just for asking, any more than that and you will have to earn it. Look at the comparables they used and find others that tilt the money in your direction. If they still won’t budge, consider hiring an independent appraiser to produce a report.

Total it. If you are close to the threshold and would prefer your car be totaled, start talking about diminished value. A car that has been in an accident and repaired is worth much less than a clean car. Appraiser Rached says, “If the owner has a solid case of diminished value, they can argue that the total claim payout (including diminished value) will exceed the vehicle’s actual cash value, forcing them to total the car for financial reasons.”

Companies like Rached’s provide appraisals supporting valid diminished-value claims.

Below are total-loss thresholds by state — the point at which a vehicle must be given a salvage title. In states without a specific threshold percentage, TLF refers to the total-loss formula: cost of repairs plus scrap value must equal the pre-accident value of the car.

Rank State Rank State Rank State
Alabama 75% Louisiana 75% Ohio TLF
Alaska TLF Maine TLF Oklahoma 60%
Arizona TLF Maryland 75% Oregon 80%
Arkansas 70% Massachusetts TLF Pennsylvania TLF
California TLF Michigan 75% Rhode Island TLF
Colorado 100% Minnesota 70% South Carolina 75%
Connecticut TLF Mississippi 70% South Dakota TLF
Delaware TLF Missouri 80% Tennessee 75%
Florida 80% Montana TLF Texas 100%
Georgia TLF Nebraska 75% Utah TLF
Hawaii TLF Nevada 65% Vermont TLF
Idaho TLF New Hampshire 75% Virginia 75%
Illinois TLF New Jersey TLF Washington TLF
Indiana 70% New Mexico TLF West Virginia 75%
Iowa 50% New York 75% Wisconsin 70%
Kansas 75% North Carolina 75% Wyoming 75%
Kentucky 75% North Dakota 75%

More on CarInsurance.com:

Sign up for our free newsletter

Like this article? Sign up for our newsletter and we'll send you a regular digest of our newest stories, full of money saving tips and advice, free! We'll also email you a PDF of Stacy Johnson's "205 Ways to Save Money" as soon as you've subscribed. It's full of great tips that'll help you save a ton of extra cash. It doesn't cost a dime, so why wait? Click here to sign up now.

Check out our hottest deals!

We're always adding new deals and coupons that'll save you big bucks. See the deals to the right and hundreds more in our Deals section.

Click here to explore 1,570 more deals!

Comments & discussion

We welcome your opinions, but let’s keep it civil. Like many businesses, we reserve the right to refuse service to anyone. In our case, that means those who communicate by name-calling, racism, using words designed to hurt others or generally acting like an uninformed bully. Also, comments that include links to email addresses or commercial websites typically aren't posted. This isn't a place to advertise your business.