Should You Use a Car-Buying Service?

Car-buying services will find and negotiate the purchase of your next new car, sometimes free of charge. They’ll definitely save you time and might save you money too.

The last two new cars I’ve bought, I never spoke to a salesman.

I bought my current vehicle in 2004 after emailing every dealer within a 50-mile radius of my house. I haggled via email with a half-dozen of them — probably spending about the same amount of time it would have taken to visit a couple of showrooms.

My car before that, a brand-new 1996 Oldsmobile, was an easier experience. I simply hired a car broker I learned about from a co-worker. The broker called me, asked what I was looking for, discussed prices and options, and went on his merry way. A week later, he found the perfect car at a near-perfect price. He even had it delivered to the parking lot at my office building.

Best I can tell, I saved a couple thousand buying a car online, and slightly less buying a car through a broker. Whether either option is right for you depends on several things, as Money Talks News founder Stacy Johnson explains in the video below. Check it out and read on for more details.

If you want to try a new way to buy a car, here are six things you need to know first:

1. Not all services are the same

The broker I hired didn’t cost me a dime. He made his money by charging the dealer. (Some brokers charge the customer a fee instead.) Brokers often have close relationships with a handful of dealers in the area who are willing to give them a discounted price because of the volume of sales.

I could’ve gone to a car concierge, who does the same thing. However, concierges generally charge customers a flat fee or a percentage of the savings they generate for the buyer. So what’s the advantage? Generally, a concierge scores deals by casting a wider net. As the name implies, concierges excel at buying luxury or harder-to-find vehicles.

Finally, there are club car-buying services available through membership organizations, such as the AAA Auto Buying Service and the Costco Auto Program. Many credit unions also offer this service, like this one from PenFed. It’s a free perk of membership, but these services are limited to the dealers that sign up with the organization.

Which service you select should depend on the answers to two questions:

  • How is the service paid? If the service is getting paid by the dealership, what gives it the incentive to find you the best possible price?
  • What services are included? Will the contract be ready for your signature? Will the car be delivered to you? Is the service simply introducing you to potential sellers? What else is involved?

2. Try selling your old car on your own

In my case, the car broker offered to include my old car in the deal for a new one. But I quickly figured out I could sell my ancient, no-frills Nissan hatchback on my own for a few hundred more. Then I had a change of heart and let the broker handle the trade-in. Why? Because I was willing to lose some value if I could gain some free time.

Do this math for yourself. If you’re willing to put in the hours, sell your trade-in and pocket the cash. If it’s too much hassle – and if you live in a small town where your customer base may be limited – consider doing what I did.

3. Do your own research

A broker, concierge or buying service can save you legwork, but you still need to do your homework. Spend some time online studying what vehicle you want, with the particular options you both crave and could do without. You want to give the service as much detail as possible.

In my case, the broker said I would save both time and money if I didn’t care what color my Oldsmobile was. So I ended up with a red car, which was fine with me.

4. Line up your financing in advance

In the video above, Stacy was adamant about financing: “Shop it and have it lined up.” He’s right. There’s no point in shopping for a car, or anything else, until you know you have the money to buy it. Shopping for a car before securing the loan is like stepping on the gas before you’re in gear: You may make a lot of noise, but you’re not going anywhere.

5. Ask what happens afterward

What happens if you get a lemon? What if you just don’t like the car when you show up on the lot or it’s delivered to your door?

Also, if you want to keep it maintained by a dealership, where’s the nearest one that services your make?

Besides the potential savings, a major advantage to embracing one of these services is sparing you time and hassle. If you don’t ask these questions up front, you could be facing complications and demands on your time after the sale.

6. Decide what your time is worth

If I had to do it all over again, would I use another broker or buy on my own? At the time I called the broker, I was starting a new job, so it was invaluable to me to have someone else handle the purchase — even worth forgoing a few hundred dollars on the sale of my old car — so I could focus on proving my value at work. And I ended up getting a great deal on the car.

Also, there wasn’t the Internet we have today, so hunting down the best deals on a new car and selling my old car would have been a time-sucking task. By 2004, that situation had changed. If you’re willing to put in the time online, you can save more – especially if you’re buying a popular, mid-priced model that many dealers have stacked on their lots.

As for me, after talking to Stacy Johnson, who’s wealthy and has never bought a new car in his life, I think I’m going to buy “pre-owned” next time.

Have you used a car buying service? Share your experience on our Facebook page.

Stacy Johnson

It's not the usual blah, blah, blah

I know... every site you visit wants you to subscribe to their newsletter. But our news and advice is actually worth reading! For 25 years, I've been making people richer without making their eyes glaze over. Take 5 seconds and join our family by clicking here. You'll be glad you did. I guarantee it!

More Money Talks News


  • Craig Bohmont

    There is a company locally that leases trucks and cars. Essentially any car or truck. However, if you want to buy, they can do that instead. Tell e’m what your preferences are…they scour all the available vehicles on all the lots…tell you whats available.
    Trade in…not exactly…they have a monthly auction, and just send you whatever yours brought at auction.

  • 23333339v2

    I normally buy 2 yr old CPO cars. Especially if I am buying a high end car. My current purchase was a M-B that was 2 years old (back from lease, most likely) with 15,000 miles on it. Original sticker on the car was about $70K and I bought it for $46K – with 85,000 miles left on the warranty (or 5 years). I keep my cars about 5 years, drive about 12K a year, and usually sell them myself when I am ready for a “new” one. I price my cars in the middle between the retail and wholesale price and they usually sell in a day or so. M-B cars are good to at least 100K miles (at 100K the engine and transmission are fine….it’s little annoying things that start to “go” – so I try to sell at around 75K miles or when I get tired of it, whichever comes first). I usually pay cash for the difference, but this last time the cost of a loan from PenFed was 0.5% so I took out a loan and paid it off in a year and a half – while the stock market was hot. I netted about 18% on my money after subtracting the 0.5% (about $4500). After my current car has 75K miles on it the retail book value will be around $30K and I should get about $24K for it, and then the process starts over again. Basically, it averages out to about $5000 a year for me to drive a $70,000 car. Buying a CPO costs about $1-2,000 more than a regular used car, but I think it’s worth it.

Check Out Our Hottest Deals!

We're always adding new deals and coupons that'll save you big bucks. See the deals to the right and hundreds more in our Deals section.

Click here to explore 2,052 more deals!