Cheryl's offers its Cheryl's Cookies Valentine's Day Sampler bundled with a $10 Cheryl's Reward Card for $9.99 with free shipping. Assuming you'll use the reward card, that's a savings of $10. It includes a buttercream frosted champagne cookie, spicy chocolate cookie, heart-shaped butter shortbread cookie, and three buttercream frosted heart-shaped cut-out cookies.