JCPenney offers three pairs of the St. John's Bay Men's Cusak Strap Sandals for $50. (Add three to your cart to see this price.) Opt for free ship-to-store pickup to dodge the $8.95 shipping fee. That's savings of $100 and the best deal we could find. They're available in sizes from 8 to 13. Buy Now
One brand takes five of the top honors, while another ranks highest in three categories.