Though Sephora and Ulta are matching this offer, other retailers are charging these prices for a single item, yielding a savings of up to $20. Shop Now at Macy's Tips Lip Primer for $16 Lip Gloss for $16 Matte Lipstick for $18 Liquid Lipstick for $20 Orders over $25 ship free; otherwise, opt for in-store pickup to avoid the $10.95 shipping charge.