What Parents Would Do With High-Tech Surveillance Tools

In their use, we might find lessons that can teach us something about Ed Snowden and the NSA.

Stuart Schechter studies these kinds of issues for Microsoft Research and discussed a recent paper that gave parents the chance to be Director of National Intelligence for a day. Sort of. Parents of teenagers were promised whiz-bang surveillance cameras and allowed to configure them in various more-or-less spooky ways. They could “spy” on kids coming in and going out the door through log files, and notify the kids they were being audited. Or they could do it secretly. They could check the log file only after getting their kids’ permission … or not. They could also “spy” on their spouses — with permission, or with notification, or secretly. I bet you know where this is going.

Default to maximum power

By default, people give themselves maximum power. Just like companies and governments are likely to do.

For example, parents were given the chance to have no log, a text log, or a photo log of their kids. Every parent chose the photo log. And every parent chose the ability to audit the comings and goings of the teens one way or another without their consent.

Most teenagers objected, like this:

“I would not like that at all. … This is like parents going psycho,” said one.

Two others mentioned that they’d start spending time at other kids’ homes if their parents installed the technology. The paper muses about other potential trust breakdowns that might arise from the technology. It’s understandable that parents might not feel they need their kids’ permission to take their picture — or to look at the history of their comings and goings. After all, parents probably don’t feel they need permission to access their kids’ Facebook accounts, though logging in without telling them probably isn’t a great idea.

It’s a little less understandable how domestic partner adults treated — read: spied on — each other. A majority gave themselves permission to spy on their partner without notice. Only 14 percent selected “only with permission.” Another 29 percent selected “anytime with notice.”

The paper concludes, in a most understated way: “Surveillance in the home can be a particularly fraught topic, with a history of debate on topics ranging from spousal wiretap to teen privacy.”

Of course, use of such technology is just an act of love — at least, that’s how the firms selling the gadgets see it. Karen Levy, a research fellow at New York University School of Law, showed a series of advertisements for family member monitoring gadgets that all invoke the language of love.

Sproutling, for example, calls itself a next-generation baby monitor. It’s a little like an ankle bracelet you might put on a paroled criminal, but Sproutling also measures other things, like heart rate. “Grow happy families” says one ad. “We’re still napping. We’ll let you know when we’re awake.”

After hearty gasps at the potential privacy implications of second-by-second data collection, the group discussed plenty of reasonable-use case scenarios. Location monitors can be helpful — even liberating — to parents of autistic children, and to families dealing with the elderly. The device could also quell anxiety about Sudden Infant Death Syndrome in infants.

On the other hand, there’s a link between being observed and being anxious — of course there is — and the group wonders if parents having an “Eye in the Sky” on their kids might make the current anxiety epidemic even worse. After all, someone says, if parents had a camera on me as a kid, there’s 1,000 experiences I wouldn’t have had. Perhaps, as we do so often in national security, we are restricting everyone’s lives to prevent a series of very low-probability events.

It’s not easy being Big Brother.

Sign up for Bob Sullivan’s free email newsletter.

Popular Articles

These 6 Lifestyle Changes Might Help Prevent Dementia
These 6 Lifestyle Changes Might Help Prevent Dementia

Science says these practices can lower the risk of cognitive decline as we age.

10 Food Staples That Are Easy and Cheap to Make Yourself
10 Food Staples That Are Easy and Cheap to Make Yourself

Making any of these key foods yourself will improve your meals and your budget — not to mention your health, in some cases.

12 ‘Disposable’ Items You Should Reuse Rather Than Throw Away
12 ‘Disposable’ Items You Should Reuse Rather Than Throw Away

Are you throwing away money? Before tossing these items that are considered disposable, consider how to give them new purpose.

View this page without ads

Help us produce more money-saving articles and videos by subscribing to a membership.

Get Started

Comments