Money Talks News

Wall St vs Main St: Who was right in 2008?

Posted on 02. Jan, 2009 by Money Talks News in Credit & Debt, Investing, Real Estate, Video

At the beginning of every year, Wall Street experts predict how it will end. But when it comes to fortune telling, is Wall Street really any smarter than Main Street? Last year at this time, we got predictions from a high-profile economist at Standard and Poors and then got similar predictions from random people at the mall. Now it’s time to look back and see who, if anyone, was right.

Let’s start with the stock market: Here’s what both Wall Street and Main Street predicted for last year.

“We’re expecting see high single digit gains, probably the 8% range.”
-David Wyss, Chief Economist Standard and Poors

And here’s what we got from a random person at the mall.

“It’s not going anywhere from where it is now. It’s going to go sideways.”
-Main Street 

So Wall Street said 08 would be up… main Street said sideways… Neither was close. When we talked to Wyss in mid-December, the Dow was down about 30%. How about the price of a barrel of crude oil?

“Your guess is as good as mine… 75 dollars is a reasonable guess, but I will be shocked if it’s right.”
-David Wyss, Chief Economist Standard and Poors 

“I think it will go up at least another one and a half percent.”
-Main Street 

Again, not even close. Oil started 2008 at around $97 a barrel, then gushed close to $150 in July. And as of mid-December, we’re under $50. So again, both Wall Street and Main Street missed the mark. Now, what about the roof over your head?

“A year from now I expect to be down about another 6%.”
-David Wyss, Chief Economist Standard and Poors  

“Housing prices will decline 5 to 7%”
-Main Street 

Bingo: both were right: as every homeowner knows, home prices have been terrible. Final tally? When it comes to predicting 2008, you were just as well off asking a stranger on Main street as a top pro on Wall Street. So much for history.

See predictions made for 2009

Related stories:

1. Wall St vs Main St: Economic Predictions for 2009
   Comparing 2009 economic predictions on the stock market, price of oil, and housing market from an expert on Wall Street and people on Main Street.
2. Bonuses Without Profit!? Wall Street, Listen Up!
   Despite the fact that most of the big Wall Street banks are only surviving courtesy of tax-payer handouts, the people who drove these businesses over a cliff, and had a hand in driving down the value of your home, are still raking in the big bucks.
3. Inflation Predictions for 2009
   According to the government, overall inflation has been low, and is expected to stay that way in 2009. But that doesn’t mean all prices are standing still. Where to look for the biggest price increases this year...
4. What To Do If You’ve Been Laid Off
   With the national unemployment rate above 7% and expected to rise, more and more Americans are finding themselves out of work. And whether you become one of them or not, it certainly pays to have a plan if it happens to you.
5. Smart Year-End Money Moves ‘08 (Part 1)
   This is the time of year when most of us spend a lot more time thinking about tree-trimming than tax-trimming. But year-end is a time when you really should do some planning.

Tags: 2008, economy, gas prices, home buying, home prices, interest rates, main street, new years, predictions, Save Money, savings, wall street