Ask Stacy: Can I Drop My Life Insurance Policy?

Just last month, I wrote about life insurance and said it’s “something you pay a lot for, then never get to use.” But that’s not always the case. Check out this recent email…

I am about to drop my whole life insurance policy, and I feel that it was a total waste of money. I have been in it for over 11 years. I have no children, my house is paid off, and I have a modest amount of money in the bank. But I pay monthly for life insurance. I feel that when the time comes, my siblings can use my savings. I have absolutely no dependents. I hope this is enough information. Please tell me, what do you think?

Thank you,
Darlene

This is a common question, Darlene. As I wrote in 8 Ways to Save on Life Insurance, it’s “probably one of the least understood major expenses.” And the insurance companies sure aren’t any help. Their ads appeal to your emotions instead of your logic. Remember that Traveler’s commercial with the cute little dog looking for a safe place to bury his bone? It was set to this catchy song called, appropriately enough, “I Just Wanna Be OK”…

Now that the musical interlude is over, let’s answer Darlene’s question…

Who needs life insurance

Darlene’s instincts are correct. Life insurance isn’t to protect you, it’s to protect those you love. If those you love don’t need protection, then you don’t need life insurance. Darlene tells us two things suggesting she can drop her policy…

  • She has no dependents. Couples often consider dropping or reducing their coverage once the kids are out of the house and onto their own careers. But Darlene doesn’t have anyone who depends on her for their financial survival: Her death may be sad for those she leaves behind, but it won’t be financially catastrophic. This is the primary reason for life insurance, and she doesn’t need it for that purpose.
  • Her house is paid off. When you die and leave your mortgaged house to a loved one, there are situations where they can automatically assume the mortgage – and others where they can’t. In either case, however, the mortgage might not be affordable. So life insurance can come in handy by paying off the mortgage. Since Darlene’s is paid off, no life insurance needed.

Was it a waste of money?

The first sentence in Darlene’s email is, “I am about to drop my whole life insurance policy, and I feel that it was a total waste of money.” As we’ve noted, Darlene doesn’t need life insurance, but in her case it may not have been a total waste of money.

That’s because Darlene has a whole life policy, as opposed to a term policy. When you buy a term policy, you have to die to get money from the insurance company. But whole life combines a death benefit with a savings account. So part of every monthly premium Darlene paid went into an interest-bearing savings account, and she’s free to tap that money whenever she wants.

Like closing a bank account, she could just surrender the policy and take her money. There might, however, be surrender penalties – something she should definitely check. She should also be aware of taxes. The interest she earned on the savings portion of her policy was tax-deferred. She didn’t pay income taxes on it. When she takes it out, she’ll have to.

An option that bypasses taxes would be to borrow against her savings (called “cash value”) with a policy loan. Low-interest loans are often made available by the insurance company for this specific purpose. Taking her money out via a loan means she doesn’t have to pay taxes. Whether this would make sense depends on the interest she’d have to pay for the loan, as well as how much interest she’s earning on her savings.

A final option would be for Darlene to stop making premium payments. In that case, the insurance company would use her accumulated savings to continue funding her death benefit until they’re used up.

What should Darlene do?

Darlene needs to contact the person or company that sold her the policy and ask a few questions…

  • First, if there’s a surrender penalty, and if so, how much.
  • Second, how much of her accumulated savings would be subject to income tax. (The money she put in isn’t taxable – only the interest it earned.)
  • Finally, she should ask about the terms on policy loans.

If there’s no penalty and the taxes aren’t too brutal, she should probably take her money and move on. Otherwise, she’ll continue paying for life insurance she doesn’t need.

If the taxes and/or penalty are big, that makes the decision more difficult. If there’s a large surrender penalty, she’ll have to balance that expense against the cost of continuing to pay the policy. If the taxes are unmanageable, she could spread the burden out over multiple years by withdrawing the money gradually.

If the premiums are unmanageable, she could ask the beneficiary – the person who will benefit on Darlene’s death – to help make them. Then she could continue paying the policy and transfer the death benefit tax-free to the beneficiary.

Bottom line? If the money involved is small, Darlene should cash in the policy and be done. If the amounts are large, she should spend a little money on an accountant to help her decide her best path.

Sign up for our free newsletter

Like this article? Sign up for our newsletter and we'll send you a regular digest of our newest stories, full of money saving tips and advice, free! We'll also email you a PDF of Stacy Johnson's '205 Ways to Save Money' as soon as you've subscribed. It's full of great tips that'll help you save a ton of extra cash. It doesn't cost a dime, so why wait? Click here to sign up now.

Are you paying too much for insurance?

In a few seconds, you can find out.

Click here for our free search tool.

Money Talks News offers a fast, free, confidential insurance search so you'll be sure you're getting the best deal.

Whether it's car, home, health or life, shopping insurance can save hundreds per year. Take a few seconds right now and see if you're paying too much.

Comments & discussion

We welcome your opinions, but let’s keep it civil. Like many businesses, we reserve the right to refuse service to anyone. In our case, that means those who communicate by name-calling, racism, using words designed to hurt others or generally acting like an uninformed bully. Also, comments that include links to email addresses or commercial websites typically aren't posted. This isn't a place to advertise your business.