Why You Shouldn’t Bother Earning That Bachelor’s Degree

By on

This post comes from Maryalene LaPonsie.

We all know the routine: You graduate from high school, head off to the college or university of your choice, and graduate four years later with a boatload of student loan debt.

But it all pays off in the end, right? That bachelor’s degree is the only way to land a prime job, and employers won’t give you a second glance without one. It’s the line we’ve been feeding ourselves and our kids for at least as long as since I was in high school.

What if it’s not true?

What if you could earn just as much, if not more, by going to school for less than half the time? That’s the suggestion of a study published this month by the American Institutes for Research. It found that while bachelor’s degrees have their place, graduates may find their first-year earnings would be more with a technical associate degree.

Some associate degrees have an $11,000 advantage

To be clear, the AIR study isn’t a comprehensive review of data from all 50 states, but it does provide an intriguing case study based upon information from Arkansas, Colorado, Tennessee, Texas and Virginia.

According to the research, in all of those states except Arkansas, first-year earnings were higher for graduates with an associate degree compared with those with a bachelor’s degree. The difference was most striking in Texas, where those with a technical associate degree earned $11,000 more in their first year working compared with those leaving school with a four-year degree.

Overall, the AIR found the following differences in first-year earnings in the five states:

  • Arkansas — $31,430 with an associate degree vs. $32,784 with a bachelor’s degree.
  • Colorado — $45,889 with an associate of applied science degree vs. $38,860 with a bachelor’s degree.
  • Tennessee — $38,954 with an associate degree vs. $37,567 with a bachelor’s degree.
  • Texas — $50,827 with a technical associate degree vs. $39,725 with a bachelor’s degree.
  • Virginia — $38,551 with a technical associate degree vs. $36,472 with a bachelor’s degree.

Study this, not that

In addition to looking at first-year earnings of graduates with two-year degrees compared with four-year degrees, the AIR considered the earning potential of specific certificate and associate degree programs.

If the study findings are to be trusted, students looking for a healthy paycheck may want to head to Texas, where the highest paying certificate and two-year degree programs were found. The Lone Star State boasts the following first-year incomes for these certificate and associate degree holders:

  • Nuclear/nuclear power technology/technician AT — $98,226.
  • Fire services administration AT — $90,317.
  • Fire prevention and safety technology/technician AT — $87,823.
  • Communications systems installation and repair technology certificate — $78,515.

On the other hand, if you enjoy eating ramen noodles, you may want to earn a bachelor’s degree in music performance. In Texas, first-year income for graduates with that degree was a paltry $15,053. Other low-paying bachelor degree programs include the four-year dietitian degree in Arkansas, which earns only $19,808 in the first year, or a bachelor’s degree in photography, which will get you a mere $20,442 in Virginia.

Don’t give up the dream of a four-year degree yet

While the AIR research certainly tarnishes the ideal of the bachelor’s degree as the gold standard of higher education, don’t totally dismiss the idea of a four-year degree just yet.

Certainly, government statistics support the idea that a bachelor’s degree offers more income-earning potential. According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, bachelor degree holders earn a median of $1,066 per week while workers with associate degrees have median incomes of $785 per week.

Instead of taking the four-year degree off the postsecondary table, the takeaway for students and parents may be to forget the automatic assumption that a bachelor’s degree is the only way to go. Certainly, associate and certificate programs shouldn’t be treated like second-rate citizens in the world of higher education.

Before you drop $34,620 for a bachelor’s degree — the average cost of four years of tuition and fees at a public university, based on 2012-2013 data from the College Board – see where $6,262 and an associate degree will get you.

Sign up for our free newsletter

Like this article? Sign up for our newsletter and we'll send you a regular digest of our newest stories, full of money saving tips and advice, free! We'll also email you a PDF of Stacy Johnson's "205 Ways to Save Money" as soon as you've subscribed. It's full of great tips that'll help you save a ton of extra cash. It doesn't cost a dime, so why wait? Click here to sign up now.

Check out our hottest deals!

We're always adding new deals and coupons that'll save you big bucks. See the deals to the right and hundreds more in our Deals section.

Click here to explore 1,096 more deals!

Comments & discussion

We welcome your opinions, but let’s keep it civil. Like many businesses, we reserve the right to refuse service to anyone. In our case, that means those who communicate by name-calling, racism, using words designed to hurt others or generally acting like an uninformed bully. Also, comments that include links to email addresses or commercial websites typically aren't posted. This isn't a place to advertise your business.

  • Michyle

    I got a Bachelor’s in Business Admin back in the 80’s
    Talk about a waste of cash.
    Before you enroll for a 4-5 year course you should do the following:
    First: Figure out how much these 4-5 years will cost you and how large a student loan you are looking at.
    Second: Try to figure out if in 4-5 years the field you have chosen is going to be saturated with graduates, (very hard to do)
    Third: Sit down and think,, Is the investment going to be worth the Return?

  • Michael Smiley Gawthrop

    This is not news to anyone who has graduated with a bachelors degree in the last couple of years… hell, I made more BEFORE I graduated than after. With no skills beyond being born with a pleasant sounding voice and having paid attention to typing classes in middle school I was able to get a job that paid $10.60 an hour. Shortly after graduating, I was laid off from that job (I didn’t really fight it because I knew it was only a matter of time before the department closed all together. It was a dying technology, the company had already started investing in what was going to replace it, and I had no interest in going into it… after all, I had a degree, I could get a better job anyway… or so I thought). After 6 months of unemployment (and I’m told I was lucky in only being out of work for 6 months), I found an amazing entry level job in accounting for, and you may want to sit down for this overwhelming salary, $10 an hour. Yes, my return on investment hasn’t just been miniscule, it has been negative. My friend who never went to college in his life, instead went to a union and got training in butchering just got a job offer for $18 an hour. So, over $30k and 5 years to take a $0.60 an hour pay cut, or no expense above lost wages and about 3 months to nearly double pay. When I reincarnate and get a second chance, I know what option I’ll take next time.

  • Lawrence Caldwell Jr

    I have a bachelors degree with a major in accounting and a minor in economics. Their is an old expression “garbage in, garbage out” that I found this true in my work as accountant. Many times I have had to fix problems caused by a lack of knowledge by the person doing the work. Just because a person can read a manual, and a lot can’t or will not, does not mean they can accurately do the work. EG. IRS tax code as an example. Also consider what happens to your body as it ages. I had to have double knee replacements. As a result there are many technical type job that I am physically unable to do.