Year-End Review: 9 Tips to Cut Homeowners Insurance Costs

With these cost-cutting tips, you can save 20 percent or more on your homeowners insurance premiums. Before the year ends, do this quick review.

Although you may dread doling out large sums of cash for your homeowners policy year after year, you can’t afford to go without it. That would be crazy. However, you don’t have to break the bank to carry suitable coverage.

It’s nearly 2015, so it’s time for a year-end review of how much you’re paying for homeowners insurance. Money Talks News founder Stacy Johnson offers some tips that can help you slash your homeowners insurance rates by 20 percent or possibly more. Watch the video below and continue reading for additional cost-cutting strategies.

1. Increase your deductible

The more liability you assume, the lower the rate you’ll pay. You can save 10 percent to 30 percent on your premium by raising your deductible from $250 to $1,000.

Afraid that you may not be able to afford the higher amount you’ll pay out-of-pocket in the event of an emergency? Beef up your emergency fund to cover the increase. That way, the money will be there when you need it, and you’ll save a substantial amount of money each year on your policy.

2. Check for multiline discounts

It pays to bundle up. According to the Insurance Information Institute, some companies will reduce the price of your policy by 5 percent to 15 percent if you purchase two or more policies with them.

3. Don’t overinsure (but don’t underinsure either)

This is often confusing to people: You want sufficient insurance to cover the cost of replacing your home from scratch, but since your lot can’t burn down, there’s no point in insuring its market value. Verify the amount your insurance company says is the replacement cost of your home by multiplying the cost per square foot for residential building in your area by the number of square feet you have.

But be careful. It’s not unusual for homeowners to underinsure, and this isn’t a place to cut corners.

Also make sure your insurance will cover the cost to replace the contents of your home with new items.

From our Solutions Center: How to quickly shop insurance

4. Shop around

For this year-end review, carve out a chunk of time to shop around for more affordable insurance. This can quickly be done on the Money Talks News Insurance page.

If you find a better deal elsewhere, ask your current insurer whether you can get a better rate. You may find you qualify for discounts you’re not aware of.

If you are considering switching companies, research the financial health of the new company. There’s no point in paying thousands in premiums and being unable to recoup any losses if you must file a claim. An analysis can be done through independent rating agencies, such as A.M. Best and Standard & Poor’s, and your state insurance department.

5. Inquire about discounts you may be eligible for

Recommended For You

Money in a Minute


  • Jason

    I agree with everything accept loyalty. I’ve found that loyalty doesn’t pay off for auto or homeowners insurance. Companies are willing to give a new customer a better deal to win business. We had our homeowners insurance with Allstate for 7 years and the premium increased every year despite the value of our house steadily dropping 30% due to the recession. The increases were only $20-$30 per year so I didn’t bother to take the time to shop around. That changed this past year when the bill came and our premium jumped from $800 to $1150! That was the kick in the pants I needed and now we have the same coverage with Progressive for $725 per year.

    • Kent

      I’ve switched several times. Progressive has good intro rates but they raise them. So far, Geico has been holding steady.

      • Jason

        We will see come April the new bill comes. Progressive can be as easily replaced as Allstate. Insurance is a commodity.

  • Paul Alldredge

    One thing to bring to any insurance agent when you want to check rates are the “deck sheets”. You get these with all the paperwork when you renew. If you can’t find them have your agent email them and share them with other companies if you want to do an apples to apples comparison. Any agent can come up with a lower fee schedule but they will change the coverage and deductibles. I check out my insurance company about every 3 years. You will be amazed what you can save if you do this. The first time I did it I realized a savings of $1,800.00 on all of my coverage when I examined the house, cars, boat and other policy stuff. If there is a significant difference give you agent the opportunity to keep your business and explain the difference or give you a good reason for not changing companies. Don’t feel bad if you do change, it is business and your money on the table.

  • Gary


    Regarding item #3 in your steps toward saving homeowner’s insurance premiums, I would point out to you that market value has nearly no relationship to reconstruction cost, on which insurance valuation is based. Some factors often overlooked by those seeking to save premium are:

    1. Demolition and Debris removal costs–$4-5000. up to $30,000, depending on many factors, but always a significant cost in the event of a total loss.

    2. “One-off” construction cost increases. A builder will spend more to build a single residence than in a development that includes many homes being constructed simultaneously.

    3. There is also the added cost of materials and labor due to inflation. Permitting, changes in building codes, as well as the builders insurance costs are also factors.

Check Out Our Hottest Deals!

We're always adding new deals and coupons that'll save you big bucks. See the deals to the right and hundreds more in our Deals section.

Click here to explore 1,596 more deals!