Ask Stacy: Do I Really Need to Wait Until Age 70 to Collect Social Security?

Many financial advisers, including me, often say to wait till the last possible minute to start taking Social Security. Why are we trying to keep people from having a nice life?


For many of us approaching retirement, collecting the maximum possible from Social Security will mean the difference between a comfortable retirement and a coupon-clipping, austere budget in our golden years. So it’s critical to understand how our national retirement system works, and the ways it can be used to better serve us as individuals.

Here’s this week’s reader question:

Why do you and others keep telling people to wait until 70 to collect Social Security? If you can afford to retire at 62, you will have eight years of good retirement that you wouldn’t have otherwise. In the meantime, the money you would have taken from your investments has additional years of growth. The longer you wait for retirement, the worse your health will be. — Ted

Ted’s right. I do often say to wait till 70 to take Social Security. For example, here’s a video we did a while back called “How to Get More Social Security.” You’ll note waiting is one of the things I suggest.

Now, on to Ted’s question:

No advice is one-size-fits-all

James Withers was my oldest friend. The only people I knew longer were my parents and sister.

A few years ago, when James was 58, he discovered he was eligible for a small pension from a long-ago stint as an elevator repairman. He called to ask my advice about the two options he was presented: a small monthly check now, or a significantly larger one when he turned 65.

Based on the advice I’ve offered about Social Security, you’d assume I told James to wait until 65. I didn’t. I told him to take it ASAP. Why? First, at the time he didn’t have two nickels to rub together. Next, his father had died at a young age, his mother had died fairly young, and his three siblings were also gone. So his odds of a long life were slimmer than most, especially considering his lifestyle wasn’t the healthiest. Last but not least, he’d recently suffered a heart attack.

Last spring I gave the eulogy at James’ funeral. I miss him. And I’m very glad I didn’t advise him to wait for his money.

The point here is that while people like me use broad strokes to address mass audiences, we’re all different, and we shouldn’t all do the same thing. Some of us will die younger, and therefore should take as much as we can get as early as we can get it. Some of us will become too frail to enjoy life at 70. Some of us have jobs we can’t wait to quit, while others can’t imagine ever quitting. Some of us have substantial nest eggs, some of us don’t.

Forget the math

If you take Social Security when you turn 62, you’ll get 25 percent less than if you wait until you turn 66. If you wait until 70, you’ll get 32 percent more than if you took your benefits at 66, and 76 percent more than you’d have gotten at 62.

But here’s something important. Theoretically there should be no difference between these options; you should receive the same basic lifetime amount under all three.

The government doesn’t reward you for waiting or penalize you for starting early. They’re simply attempting to pay you what you’re owed over your lifetime. Doing that requires smaller checks for a longer period if you take it early or larger ones for a shorter period if you wait.

So when Ted says, “If you can afford to retire at 62, you will have eight years of good retirement that you wouldn’t have otherwise,” he’s absolutely right, provided the income you’ll receive at 62 will be enough to live on for the rest of your life.

He also says, “In the meantime, the money you would have taken from your investments has additional years of growth.” Also true. But that assumes that those not retiring at 62 are depleting, rather than adding to, their investments. If you keep working past 62, the paychecks you’re getting should be keeping you alive and building your savings.

So here’s the bottom line: My hope for Ted, and for you, is that you retire whenever you want to. If you want to stop working and can enjoy a quality retirement by taking your Social Security when you’re 62, please do. And if you expect a shorter life than most, or face poor health in your retirement years, definitely take the money and run.

Now, here are some tips to maximize your Social Security.

1. Work at least 35 years

Social Security benefits are calculated based on your 35 highest-earning working years. If you work fewer years, you’ll have years with zero income averaged in, which will lower your payout.

2. Ask for a raise

The more you make while working, the more you’ll make in Social Security, to a limit. So make as much as you can. Getting a second job is another way to accomplish the same thing.

3. Use online tools

If you’re unsure about the best time to claim benefits based on your individual budget, health, life expectancy or other factors, use online resources to help you decide. A good place to start is SocialSecurity.gov/MyAccount, where you’ll get your personalized statement. This estimates what your benefits will be at age 62, at full retirement age, or at age 70.

Once you get estimates for both you and, if applicable, your spouse, there are other online tools that compare your benefits under various scenarios to help you determine the best claiming strategy. AARP has a Social Security Benefits Calculator. Another option is to get a personalized analysis and claiming strategy. We can hook you up with that on this page of our Solutions Center.

Check Out Our Hottest Deals!

We're always adding new deals and coupons that'll save you big bucks. See the deals to the right and hundreds more in our Deals section.

Click here to explore 1,547 more deals!