How to Make Great Homemade Yogurt

By on

I never cared much for yogurt. It generally seemed too sour to me, unless it was turned into tzatziki sauce on a gyro sandwich.

Apparently, I just never had the right kind of yogurt.

I’d heard that the homemade version was better than the commercial kind. I’d also read about people making yogurt in a slow cooker. After looking online for instructions I settled on the process described at A Year of Slow Cooking.

And then I improved on it.

It’s time-consuming but very simple:

  • Pour two quarts of milk into a slow cooker.
  • Cover and cook on low for 2½ hours.
  • Unplug the slow cooker and let stand, covered, for 3 hours.
  • Pour 2 cups of the milk into a bowl and whisk in ½ cup of an active-culture yogurt; put the mixture back into the slow cooker and stir to combine.
  • Put the lid back on and wrap the entire slow cooker in a heavy bath towel to insulate.
  • Let stand for 8 hours.

I start it after supper and by bedtime it’s time to wrap the slow cooker. When I get up the next morning, I’ve got two quarts of yogurt.

In theory.

No whey!

Most commercial yogurts use some sort of thickening agent, such as pectin. Homemade yogurt is much thinner, and a little tangier than I’d like. It would be great for smoothies, but I wanted to eat the stuff from a dish. Without wincing.

The author, Stephanie O’Dea, suggests creating “a Greek-style yogurt” by straining the product through a coffee filter-lined colander. I used a flour-sack towel from the dollar store instead, since it’s washable vs. disposable. (It’s the same towel I used to strain the grapes that I gleaned from a neighboring fence.)

I poured in about a cup at a time and set the colander over a bowl in the fridge. The whey dripped through, leaving a thick, creamy, and milder-tasting yogurt. I spooned it out and into a jar, then poured in another cup. Ultimately, I ended up with a quart of finished product.

It takes hours to drain the whole batch. But during this time frame I’m doing other things, just as the yogurt setting-up happens while I’m asleep.

The result is delicious: rich, smooth and not at all sour, although a subtle tang remains. It’s wonderful with fruit – as good as ice cream but healthier. I’ve had it with sliced bananas, applesauce (made from a 99-cent bag of “manager’s special” fruit), homemade jams, and gleaned, stewed rhubarb. This summer I’m looking forward to eating it with free blackberries.

A dollop makes baked potatoes quite tasty. Mixed with salsa, it made a nice sauce for a side dish of pinto beans.

Yes, whey

Throwing out the separated liquid seemed like a bad idea. Why waste all that whey protein?

Thus far I’ve poured it into soup stock, chili, and spaghetti sauce. Each morning I fix my super-easy, super-cheap oatmeal with half water and half whey. The flavor is yogurty, but not at all sour.

I’m hoping to make yogurt while in Anchorage, using a slow cooker borrowed from my niece. Milk here is more expensive thanks to the Alaska gouge, so I’ll watch for sales and/or close-dated moo juice. In Seattle, I’ve paid as little as $1.25 per half-gallon. Initially I had to buy a container of yogurt for starter; after that, I just saved half a cup from each batch. (Note: The starter doesn’t have to be strained.)

I’m delighted to have found a palatable way to get more calcium in my diet. I don’t like to drink milk, and I don’t often eat spinach, mustard greens, tofu, canned salmon, or other high-calcium foods. Despite a daily supplement, I’m concerned about my teeth and bones. The probiotic benefits of yogurt are a plus too.

If you’ve got the time, I’d strongly suggest firing up your own slow cooker. You can paint this as an eco-friendly move: How many little plastic containers are you throwing away each month?

Or you can look at it as a frugal hack. I got a quart of high-quality product for $1.25 or so. How much are you paying per cup or carton?

I haven’t tried making my own tzatziki yet. But give me time and a few cucumbers and I probably will.

More stories by Donna Freedman

Sign up for our free newsletter

Like this article? Sign up for our newsletter and we'll send you a regular digest of our newest stories, full of money saving tips and advice, free! We'll also email you a PDF of Stacy Johnson's "205 Ways to Save Money" as soon as you've subscribed. It's full of great tips that'll help you save a ton of extra cash. It doesn't cost a dime, so why wait? Click here to sign up now.

Check out our hottest deals!

We're always adding new deals and coupons that'll save you big bucks. See the deals to the right and hundreds more in our Deals section.

Click here to explore 1,058 more deals!

Comments & discussion

We welcome your opinions, but let’s keep it civil. Like many businesses, we reserve the right to refuse service to anyone. In our case, that means those who communicate by name-calling, racism, using words designed to hurt others or generally acting like an uninformed bully. Also, comments that include links to email addresses or commercial websites typically aren't posted. This isn't a place to advertise your business.