Ask Stacy: Are Online Retirement Calculators Reliable?

Retirement Calculator
Photo by one photo / Shutterstock.com

Welcome to “Ask Stacy,” a short video feature answering money questions submitted by readers and viewers. You can learn how to send in a question of your own below.

If you’re not typically a video watcher, give it a try. These videos are short and painless, and you’ll learn something valuable. But if you can’t deal with video, no problem: Just scroll down this page for the full transcript of the video, as well as some reader resources.

Today’s question is about retirement calculators; specifically, whether they’re worth your time.

Online calculators seem like a great idea. You input information — like your age, risk tolerance and the amount you’re saving monthly — and the calculator instantly tells you whether you’ll be spending your golden years partying or Dumpster-diving.

There’s only one problem: Unlike actual calculators, these “calculators” often give completely different answers for identical inputs. Here’s why.

I wrote an article years ago about why I hate all types of online calculators. See “5 Reasons Online Calculators Don’t Add Up.”

For more information on retirement planning, check out “7 Tips for Stress-Free Retirement Plan Investing” and “Ready to Rescue Your Retirement in 2018? Here’s How.” You can also go to the search at the top of this page, put in the word “retirement” and find plenty of information on just about everything relating to this topic.

Got a question of your own to ask? Scroll down past the transcript.

Don’t want to watch? Here’s what I said in the video

Stacy Johnson: Hello, everyone, and welcome to your money Q&A question of the day. I’m your host, Stacy Johnson.

This question is brought to you by MoneyTalksNews.com, serving up the best in personal finance news since 1991.

Here we go with today’s question. It is from Lisa. Lisa says, “I’m 46. I’ve been saving for retirement since 16. I’m confused how one retirement planning website says I will be way short on money for retirement, another says I’m going to have way too much and a third says I’m just barely going to make it. How can this be?”

Well, Lisa, this can be because these calculators are a bunch of crap.

In my second book, “Money Made Simple,” which I wrote 15 years ago, I compared using a simple method for investment allocation — one you can do in your head — to using a sophisticated online calculator. Guess what? My simple method came out with the exact same asset allocation as a complex calculator. Ever since that little experiment, I’ve placed little weight on these things.

Here are three things to consider when you’re looking at online calculators.

First, the longer the term the calculator is computing for, the less accurate it’s going to be. Why? Because retirement calculators force you to make assumptions. They say, “How much do you expect to earn? How long do you expect to live? When are you going to retire?” Even changing something as simple as 5 percent to 6 percent on how much you expect to earn can change the results radically when you expand that over decades of time.

What was Lisa? 46? The calculator is asking her to make assumptions that are going to occur 20 years from now. It’s no wonder these calculators come up with different answers.

This leads me to point number two: Calculators can be useful, but they’re really more of a novelty than they are a serious planning tool. I wouldn’t put too much weight on calculators — and don’t be surprised, Lisa, when they come up with different results.

The third point I want to make is when you make a plan — and obviously, we should try to plan for our retirement — be flexible.

Here’s a confession: I’m 62, and I don’t really have a specific plan. I know that may sound weird because this is the business I’m in, but I really don’t have one. I’ve simply tried to save as much as I can. It’s worked out: I’ve saved enough so I can retire tomorrow. But the reason I don’t have a solid plan is because my life has changed in ways I couldn’t possibly foresee.

For example, when I was 57, I married someone 23 years younger than me. That changed everything. My wife loves her job and will continue to work, which means I might as well continue working, too. Who could see that coming?

Another factor: My business makes way more money some years than other years, which makes it basically impossible to get specific when it comes to creating a long-term plan.

Bottom line? I don’t rely on calculators or create specific benchmarks. I max out my retirement plans every year. I put aside as much money as I’m able and then I let the chips fall where they may. For me, that’s worked out pretty well.

I hope that answers your question, Lisa.

Let’s close today with our financial expression of the day. This one comes from Dorothy Parker. It’s one of my favorites.

“If you want to know what God thinks of money, just look at the people he gave it to.”

Like that one? Spread it around today and be sure to be back here next time.

Make it a profitable day!

Got a question you’d like answered?

You can ask a question simply by hitting “reply” to our email newsletter, just as you would any email in your inbox. If you’re not subscribed, fix that right now by clicking here. It’s free, only takes a few seconds, and will get you valuable information every day!

The questions I’m likeliest to answer are those that will interest other readers. In other words, don’t ask for super-specific advice that applies only to you. And if I don’t get to your question, promise not to hate me. I do my best, but I get a lot more questions than I have time to answer.

About me

I founded Money Talks News in 1991. I’m a CPA, and have also earned licenses in stocks, commodities, options principal, mutual funds, life insurance, securities supervisor and real estate.

Got any words of wisdom you can offer on this week’s question? Share your knowledge and experiences on our Facebook page. And if you find this information useful, please share it!

Got more money questions? Browse lots more Ask Stacy answers here.

Disclosure: The information you read here is always objective. However, we sometimes receive compensation when you click links within our stories.

Read Next
8 Reasons Your Parents Had an Easier Retirement Than You Will
8 Reasons Your Parents Had an Easier Retirement Than You Will

Here’s why the last decades of life are harder now than they used to be.

5 Surveys For Money Sites To Get Paid For Your Opinion
5 Surveys For Money Sites To Get Paid For Your Opinion

Yes, you can earn extra cash by taking online surveys. But some websites are better than others for this. Here are a few of our favorites.

11 ‘Disposable’ Items You Should Be Reusing
16 Products That Coffee Drinkers Will Love
16 Products That Coffee Drinkers Will Love

We’ve brewed up a list of amazing Amazon products that are sure to perk you up.

6 Reasons You Should Stop Hiding Cash at Home
6 Reasons You Should Stop Hiding Cash at Home

Stashing money around the house is anything but harmless.

View this page without ads

Help us produce more money-saving articles and videos by subscribing to a membership.

Get Started

Most Popular
7 Kirkland Signature Items to Avoid at Costco
7 Kirkland Signature Items to Avoid at Costco

Even if it seems you save a bundle buying Costco’s Kirkland Signature brand products, they may not be the bargain they appear to be.

How to Buy Gas At Costco Without a Membership
How to Buy Gas At Costco Without a Membership

The warehouse club often has some of the cheapest gas in town. Here’s how you can get it as a nonmember.

10 Things to Stop Buying If You Want a Clutter-Free Home
10 Things to Stop Buying If You Want a Clutter-Free Home

If you like to keep things simple, avoid these purchases.

A Simple Way to Silence Robocalls Today
A Simple Way to Silence Robocalls Today

A few steps can keep your phone from ringing when a spammer calls.

This Company Makes the Best Tires in America
This Company Makes the Best Tires in America

Driver satisfaction with tires is at an all-time high, but one brand stands out.

If You Find This Thrift Shopping, Buy It
If You Find This Thrift Shopping, Buy It

Vacuums from this brand can last a half-century, if not longer — and they’re hot on the resale market.

This Health Issue Can Hint at Dementia Years in Advance
This Health Issue Can Hint at Dementia Years in Advance

One type of pain is especially associated with cognitive decline.

If You Find This Thrift Shopping, Buy It
If You Find This Thrift Shopping, Buy It

This iconic dinnerware is prized for everyday use as well as reselling for profit.

Can I Switch to Spousal Social Security Benefits When My Ex Dies?
Can I Switch to Spousal Social Security Benefits When My Ex Dies?

Knowing when to claim can help you maximize benefits.

Medicare Will Not Cover These 6 Medical Costs
Medicare Will Not Cover These 6 Medical Costs

Don’t let these health care expenses catch you off guard in retirement.

8 Things You Should Always Buy on Amazon
8 Things You Should Always Buy on Amazon

The giant retailer shines when it comes to these things, from basics to hard-to-find specialty goods.

Beware This Hidden Ingredient in Rotisserie Chicken
Beware This Hidden Ingredient in Rotisserie Chicken

Something foul may lurk in those delicious, ready-to-eat birds.

5 Ways to Get Amazon Prime for Free
5 Ways to Get Amazon Prime for Free

Hesitant to drop $119 a year on an Amazon Prime membership? Here’s how to get it for free.

5 Ways to Fill Your Pantry With Free Food
5 Ways to Fill Your Pantry With Free Food

Anyone can take advantage of these resources.

5 States With the Worst Health Care for Retirees
5 States With the Worst Health Care for Retirees

All of these states are located in the same region of the nation.

7 Big Purchases You Should Never Make
7 Big Purchases You Should Never Make

Sometimes a big-ticket purchase is nothing more than a big waste of money.

3 Ways to Get Microsoft Office for Free
3 Ways to Get Microsoft Office for Free

With a little ingenuity, you can cut Office costs to zero.

5 Products You Should Never Buy Generic
5 Products You Should Never Buy Generic

Sometimes the brand-name version is clearly superior.

This Cellphone Carrier Has the Worst Network Quality, Customers Say
This Cellphone Carrier Has the Worst Network Quality, Customers Say

One major wireless provider stands out for the least reliable call, messaging and data services.

View More Articles

View this page without ads

Help us produce more money-saving articles and videos by subscribing to a membership.

Get Started

Add a Comment

Our Policy: We welcome relevant and respectful comments in order to foster healthy and informative discussions. All other comments may be removed. Comments with links are automatically held for moderation.