Consumer Group Blasts Auto Insurers for Paltry Low-Mileage Discounts

car costs
Photo by kurhan / Shutterstock.com

If you’re hoping for a car insurance discount because you or someone else on your policy doesn’t drive much, you better shop around.

Recent research by the nonprofit Consumer Federation of American (CFA) shows that while spending less time behind the wheel lessens your odds of getting into a crash, not all major auto insurers offer significant discounts to low-mileage drivers.

On average, folks outside of California save $30 per year, or 1.6 percent, for every 5,000 fewer miles driven. That’s compared with an average savings of $81, or 8.7 percent, in California — which is an exception because its regulations require insurers to charge lower-mileage drivers less.

Analyzing mileage discounts

For its research, CFA got premium quotes for basic liability coverage in 12 different U.S. cities — one in California, and the rest elsewhere. The quotes were from five large auto insurers:

  • Allstate
  • Farmers
  • Geico
  • Progressive
  • State Farm

The quotes all were for a driver with an unblemished record. So, the only differences between quotes, besides the insurers and the cities, was the number of miles driven per year. Annual mileage varied from 2,500 to 22,500.

How the 5 insurers fared

From one insurer to another, low-mileage discounts vary from nonexistent to double digits.

CFA singled out Farmers and Progressive as being particularly stingy in the 11 non-California cities included in CFA’s analysis:

Progressive and Farmers usually charge the same rates to someone who drives only 2,500 miles a year as they charge someone else who drives 22,500 miles a year — nine times as far — all else being equal.

Geico offers “a small price reduction” for lower-mileage drivers outside California, CFA found. Allstate and State Farm offer average reductions of 11 percent and 13 percent, respectively, outside California.

CFA argues that car insurance rates should be based more on driving-related factors such as mileage than on socioeconomic factors like your credit score or marital status.

J. Robert Hunter, director of CFA and a former Texas insurance commissioner, notes:

“For people in most parts of the country, with California as the notable exception, you’ll often pay about the same auto insurance premium whether you commute 90 miles round trip every day or if you take public transit to work and only drive on the weekends.”

For its part, Progressive says on its website that it normally does not ask policyholders to report their mileage, but that it does reward low-mileage drivers through its Snapshot program, which monitors driving behavior in exchange for discounted rates.

Farmers says on its website that drivers who limit their time behind the wheel “may therefore enjoy low-mileage discounts.”

Nonetheless, until laws change outside of California, consider this a reminder of the importance of periodically shopping your insurance policies around to confirm you’re getting the best rates for which you can qualify.

What’s your experience with car insurance discounts like low-mileage discounts? Share with us below or on Facebook.

Disclosure: The information you read here is always objective. However, we sometimes receive compensation when you click links within our stories.

Read Next
The 5 Worst Home Upgrades for the Money
The 5 Worst Home Upgrades for the Money

These home improvement projects basically never pay off.

3 Easy Ways to Get Laundry Soap for Nearly Nothing
3 Easy Ways to Get Laundry Soap for Nearly Nothing

Not using any of these methods for saving on laundry detergent? Then, you are washing money down the drain.

10 U.S. Jobs That Are Disappearing Fastest
10 U.S. Jobs That Are Disappearing Fastest

Think twice before pursuing these shrinking occupations.

5 Home Improvements That Help You ‘Age in Place’
5 Home Improvements That Help You ‘Age in Place’

These safety-conscious home upgrades can help retirees stay in their home.

6 Reasons I Will Never Trust Suze Orman
6 Reasons I Will Never Trust Suze Orman

Beware: The self-proclaimed personal finance expert has a track record that suggests more sizzle than steak.

View this page without ads

Help us produce more money-saving articles and videos by subscribing to a membership.

Get Started

Most Popular
10 Things Frugal People Never Buy
10 Things Frugal People Never Buy

If you’re a true tightwad, the mere thought of spending money on these items gives you the willies.

10 Useless Purchases You Need to Stop Making
10 Useless Purchases You Need to Stop Making

You might as well flush your money down the loo if you spend it on these things.

7 Social Security Benefits You May Be Overlooking
7 Social Security Benefits You May Be Overlooking

There’s more to Social Security than retirement benefits.

7 Social Security Rules Everyone Should Know by Now
7 Social Security Rules Everyone Should Know by Now

Confusion over Social Security is a shame, considering how many of us will need this money badly.

If You Find This Thrift Shopping, Buy It
If You Find This Thrift Shopping, Buy It

They don’t make coffee makers like this anymore.

3 Ways to Get Microsoft Office for Free
3 Ways to Get Microsoft Office for Free

With a little ingenuity, you can cut Office costs to zero.

The 6 Best Investing Apps for Beginners
The 6 Best Investing Apps for Beginners

If you’re looking to ease into investing in the coronavirus economy with just a little money, check out these easy-to-use tools.

14 Things You Should Stop Buying in 2021
14 Things You Should Stop Buying in 2021

These convenient household products come with hidden costs that you might not have considered.

Is Writing a Check Still Safe?
Is Writing a Check Still Safe?

Every time you pay by check, you hand your bank account numbers to a stranger.

8 Things You Should Replace to Improve Your Life Today
8 Things You Should Replace to Improve Your Life Today

Being frugal isn’t smart if you put off replacing these items.

7 Kirkland Signature Items to Avoid at Costco
7 Kirkland Signature Items to Avoid at Costco

Even if it seems you save a bundle buying Costco’s Kirkland Signature brand products, they may not be the bargain they appear to be.

9 Things You Should Never Leave in a Car
9 Things You Should Never Leave in a Car

Thinking of leaving these possessions in a car? Prepare for unexpected consequences.

9 Mistakes People Make When Cleaning With Vinegar
9 Mistakes People Make When Cleaning With Vinegar

Cleaning with vinegar can save you a lot of money, but using it like this can cost you.

13 Amazon Purchases We Are Loving Right Now
13 Amazon Purchases We Are Loving Right Now

These practical products make everyday life a little easier.

10 Deep Discounts Available on Amazon This Friday
10 Deep Discounts Available on Amazon This Friday

These items are all steeply discounted — but the deals won’t last long.

7 Income Tax Breaks That Retirees Often Overlook
7 Income Tax Breaks That Retirees Often Overlook

Did you realize all these tax credits and deductions exist — or that they apply to retirees?

7 Hidden Sections of Amazon Every Shopper Should Know
7 Hidden Sections of Amazon Every Shopper Should Know

These little-known departments of Amazon are gold mines for deal-seekers and impulse shoppers alike.

10 Cars You Are Most Likely to Keep for 15 Years
10 Cars You Are Most Likely to Keep for 15 Years

The cars that owners hold onto the longest have one thing in common, a new study shows.

10 Things Successful Retirees Do Differently
10 Things Successful Retirees Do Differently

These habits and characteristics can help put you on the track to success.

View More Articles

View this page without ads

Help us produce more money-saving articles and videos by subscribing to a membership.

Get Started

Add a Comment

Our Policy: We welcome relevant and respectful comments in order to foster healthy and informative discussions. All other comments may be removed. Comments with links are automatically held for moderation.