Ask Stacy: Should I Save More for Retirement or Pay Down My Mortgage?

If you had extra money, what would you do with it: destroy some debt or beef up your savings? The answer can vary depending on your circumstances.

Here’s this week’s question:

I turned 65 last month and I’m still working full time and wanted to get your opinion on whether you think it’s best for someone my age to sock away extra cash or pay down my mortgage? I don’t have enough in my 401(k) to retire on, and I still have a mortgage balance of a little over 100K on my home. I plan on working for at least 3-5 years or more and would like your opinion on whether you think saving for more cash on hand is better or paying down/paying off the mortgage is the best move for me?
– Retha

The short answer, Retha, is you’ll probably be better off putting as much as possible into your retirement account rather than paying down your mortgage. Let’s take a closer look.

Retirement plan vs. mortgage: the math

In a working paper called The Tradeoff Between Mortgage Prepayments and Tax-Deferred Retirement Savings (summarized at this page of the National Bureau of Economic Research website), several academics examined the mortgage vs. savings equation and came to this conclusion: “38 percent of U.S. households that are accelerating their mortgage payments instead of saving in tax-deferred accounts are making the wrong choice.”

Why would nearly 40 percent of people be better off socking away retirement savings vs. paying down their mortgage? In a word, taxes. For most people, mortgage interest is tax-deductible, retirement plan contributions are deductible and their earnings are tax deferred.

This tax arbitrage makes retirement contributions a better choice, at least for some.

Example: Say you pay 4 percent on your mortgage, and you’re in the 25 percent tax bracket. Every deductible dollar you pay in mortgage interest reduces your taxable income by a dollar, which saves you 25 cents in taxes. The net effect: Your after-tax cost of borrowing isn’t 4 percent, it’s 3 percent, because Uncle Sam effectively pays a quarter of it.

At the same time, when you contribute $4,000 to a traditional retirement account, that’s $4,000 you’re not taxed on, which saves you $1,000 in taxes. You’ll have to pay taxes on that money and the interest it earns when it’s withdrawn, but theoretically you could be in a lower tax bracket when that occurs.

Those deriving the maximum benefit from this tax arbitrage will be those in the highest tax brackets, earning the most on their retirement savings for the longest periods of time.

One other note: If your employer is matching your retirement contributions, this is a no-brainer. You never turn down free money, so you always contribute enough to your company plan to get as much matching money as possible.

Dave Ramsey takes on the retirement vs. mortgage question and arrives at a similar conclusion here. Forbes agrees in this article.

After maxing out retirement contributions

The most Retha can contribute to her 401(k) for 2016 is $24,000: $18,000 in regular contributions and, because she’s older than 50, $6,000 in catchup contributions. (See limits at this page of the IRS website.) After maxing out her 401(k), should she add extra money to her savings or use it to pay down her mortgage?

Here the math is simpler.

If Retha is in the 25 percent bracket and has a 4 percent mortgage, we’ve established that her after-tax interest cost is 3 percent. That means unless she can earn more than 3 percent after-tax on her savings, she’d be money ahead by paying down her mortgage.

Put another way, if she’s paying 3 percent on her mortgage and earning 1 percent at the bank, she’s getting 2 percent poorer every year.

But I still wouldn’t suggest paying down her mortgage. Instead, I’d suggest leaving the mortgage in place and trying to earn more than 3 percent after-tax, at least for part of her savings, by taking a little more risk.

For example, after accumulating a hefty emergency fund, she might look into peer-to-peer lending, or dividend-paying stocks. From real estate to mutual funds, there are ways to beat the bank without taking on excessive risk. Depending on her tolerance for risk, willingness to learn and the size of her cash cushion, she should look into some.

Other considerations

So far, it’s been all about the math. But earning more than you’re paying isn’t the only consideration.

While living debt-free is a great goal, accumulating a pile of cash is critical, especially for those approaching retirement. Retha says she doesn’t have enough in her 401(k) to retire on, and it’s not hard to imagine a scenario where she’s either unable or unwilling to continue working. Should that happen, cash will be king. If push comes to shove, she could rid herself of the mortgage debt by selling her house and downsizing. But once she quits working, she has no way to generate more savings. So that’s where the priority lies.

Bottom line? Job one for people in Retha’s position should be to put aside as much as possible in tax-advantaged retirement accounts. Priority two should be saving as much as possible outside of retirement accounts. Only after building a comfortable cushion should you use spare cash to pay down a mortgage.

Got a question you’d like answered?

A great way to get answers to just about any money-related question is to head to our Forums. It’s the place where you can speak your mind, explore topics in-depth and, most important, post questions and get answers. It’s also where I often look for questions to answer in this weekly column. You can also ask questions by replying to our daily emails. If you’re not getting them, fix that right now by subscribing here.

About me

I founded Money Talks News in 1991. I’ve a CPA, and have also earned licenses in stocks, commodities, options principal, mutual funds, life insurance, securities supervisor and real estate. Got some time to kill? You can learn more about me here.

Got more money questions? Browse lots more Ask Stacy answers here.

Disclosure: The information you read here is always objective. However, we sometimes receive compensation when you click links within our stories.

Read Next
14 Things That Are ‘Free’ With Medicare
14 Things That Are ‘Free’ With Medicare

These services could save you money and help prevent costly health problems.

7 Kitchen Gadgets That Make Healthy Cooking a Breeze
7 Kitchen Gadgets That Make Healthy Cooking a Breeze

These small appliances and cooking aids make healthy eating easy — and they’re all available on Amazon.

These Are the 3 Best Used Cars You Can Buy
These Are the 3 Best Used Cars You Can Buy

These vehicles boast reliability, safety and long-lasting value.

How to Get the Best Possible Deal on Car Insurance
How to Get the Best Possible Deal on Car Insurance

This is the last article on understanding and shopping for car insurance that you’ll ever need.

What’s the Difference Between FICO and VantageScore Credit Scores?
What’s the Difference Between FICO and VantageScore Credit Scores?

There are lots of credit scores out there, but if you’re keeping an eye on your credit, here’s the one to watch.

View this page without ads

Help us produce more money-saving articles and videos by subscribing to a membership.

Get Started

Most Popular
7 Kirkland Signature Items to Avoid at Costco
7 Kirkland Signature Items to Avoid at Costco

Even if it seems you save a bundle buying Costco’s Kirkland Signature brand products, they may not be the bargain they appear to be.

If You Find This Thrift Shopping, Buy It
If You Find This Thrift Shopping, Buy It

Whether you resell it for a big profit or add it to your own wardrobe, this type of clothing is a hidden steal.

3 Ways to Get Microsoft Office for Free
3 Ways to Get Microsoft Office for Free

With a little ingenuity, you can cut Office costs to zero.

9 Things You’ll Never See at Costco Again
9 Things You’ll Never See at Costco Again

The warehouse store offers an enormous selection, but these products aren’t coming back.

Organize Your Home With These 10 Thrift Store Finds
Organize Your Home With These 10 Thrift Store Finds

Resolve to be clutter-free in 2021 with these secondhand purchases.

11 Laws You Could Be Breaking Without Knowing It
11 Laws You Could Be Breaking Without Knowing It

Seriously? Fibbing about the weather is a crime? This and other little-known legal traps await the unwary.

Is This Treatable Condition Causing Your High Blood Pressure?
Is This Treatable Condition Causing Your High Blood Pressure?

Researchers say too many doctors are overlooking this potential source of hypertension.

13 Things Seniors Can Get for Free — or Almost Free
13 Things Seniors Can Get for Free — or Almost Free

There are many ways to get cheap or free services and goods after reaching a certain age.

Taking a Multivitamin? Here’s Why You Should Reconsider
Taking a Multivitamin? Here’s Why You Should Reconsider

A new study has bad news for the millions of Americans who spend money on multivitamins.

Does Wearing 2 Masks Protect You Better From COVID-19?
Does Wearing 2 Masks Protect You Better From COVID-19?

A growing number of people are wearing two masks instead of just one. Should you join them?

21 Items to Cut From Your Budget That You Won’t Even Miss
21 Items to Cut From Your Budget That You Won’t Even Miss

Start off the new year by implementing these small-but-smart savings strategies. They’ll soon add up.

This Is America’s New Favorite Grocery Store
This Is America’s New Favorite Grocery Store

Consumers say a familiar name has become their go-to source of grocery items.

Internet Providers Can’t Charge You for This Anymore
Internet Providers Can’t Charge You for This Anymore

Starting this month, your ISP no longer can bill you for this fee.

This Surprise Factor Can Raise Your Risk of Dementia
This Surprise Factor Can Raise Your Risk of Dementia

Nearly half of U.S. residents may face this threat.

15 Painless Ways You Can Cut Costs in 2021
15 Painless Ways You Can Cut Costs in 2021

Follow these tips to save, so you’ll have money for things that really matter.

10 Cars You Are Most Likely to Keep for 15 Years
10 Cars You Are Most Likely to Keep for 15 Years

The cars that owners hold onto the longest have one thing in common, a new study shows.

Prepare to Pay More for These 31 Drugs in 2021
Prepare to Pay More for These 31 Drugs in 2021

More than 700 prescription medications have seen price hikes so far this year. Here’s a look at the worst.

The 10 Golden Rules of Becoming a Millionaire
The 10 Golden Rules of Becoming a Millionaire

I’m a millionaire several times over. I got here the same way you can — by following these simple steps.

5 States Lowering Taxes This Year and 2 Raising Them
5 States Lowering Taxes This Year and 2 Raising Them

State personal income tax rates, brackets and deductions just changed in these places.

View More Articles

View this page without ads

Help us produce more money-saving articles and videos by subscribing to a membership.

Get Started

Add a Comment

Our Policy: We welcome relevant and respectful comments in order to foster healthy and informative discussions. All other comments may be removed. Comments with links are automatically held for moderation.