This Car Insurer Handles Claims Best, Drivers Say (Again)

Advertising Disclosure: When you buy something by clicking links on our site, we may earn a small commission, but it never affects the products or services we recommend.

Happy male driver
pakww /

Auto insurers continue to struggle to get repaired cars back on the road — but surprisingly, that fact isn’t fueling resentment among policyholders.

Customer satisfaction with auto insurance companies rose 5 points on a 1,000-point scale in J.D. Power’s latest annual U.S. Auto Claims Satisfaction Study.

The average time to complete auto insurance repairs stretched to 23.1 days in 2023, up 6.2 days from 2022. Average repair time is now more than double what it was in 2021.

Yet, J.D. Power says insurers are doing a good job of managing customer expectations, and that has helped the industry to improve its customer satisfaction ratings.

In a summary of the study findings, Mark Garrett, director of global insurance intelligence at J.D. Power, says:

“It’s really a testament to strong client management processes and improved digital communications. Insurers have been able to earn significantly higher auto claim satisfaction scores at a time when costs and rates are rising — even though it’s never taken longer to get a vehicle repaired.”

The survey polled 9,659 auto insurance customers who settled a claim in the nine months prior to the survey. Customer satisfaction improved in nearly every category, including:

  • Settlement
  • First notice of loss
  • Claim servicing
  • Estimation process
  • Repair process

Satisfaction fell in just one category, rental experience.

For the second straight year, Amica Mutual was the top insurer, garnering a score of 909 out of 1,000. That topped the study’s average score of 878.

The list of insurers that exceeded the industry average is as follows:

  • Amica Mutual: 909
  • Erie Insurance: 902
  • NJM Insurance Co.: 900
  • Country Financial: 894
  • State Farm: 891
  • Auto Club of Southern California Insurance Group: 889
  • Auto-Owners Insurance: 888
  • Allstate: 882
  • American Family: 882
  • Safeco: 880
  • Shelter: 879

USAA earned a customer satisfaction score of 900 for claims. But the insurer, which only serves military members and their families, was excluded from J.D. Power’s rankings.

Are you looking for a new car insurance company? You don’t have to spend time calling around to different insurers for quotes. Services such as QuoteWizard gather quotes for you so you can pick the best rate.

Get smarter with your money!

Want the best money-news and tips to help you make more and spend less? Then sign up for the free Money Talks Newsletter to receive daily updates of personal finance news and advice, delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for our free newsletter today.