Holiday Spending Stress Is High. How to Talk About Cutting Back Gifts

USA TODAY Network / Reuters

Financial stress is high on the holiday list for shoppers this season. So how can you cut back on spending without it seeming awkward or that you’re a Scrooge?

More than half of Americans in a new survey are worried about money this holiday season, with 32% feeling pressure to overspend and 30% dipping into emergency savings to get through the holiday.

There is excitement going into the holiday season “coupled with this financial stress that many Americans are feeling,” Courtney Alev, Intuit Credit Karma consumer financial advocate, told USA TODAY.

Pressure to Overspend Is High

Some shoppers are starting the holiday season already in debt: 34% of respondents said they had existing credit card debt.

But some shoppers are prepared to break their budget or even postpone paying a bill to satisfy those on their shopping list.

Younger shoppers in particular are facing pressure to overspend, with 43% of Gen Z and 44% of millennials saying they feel the strain. Roughly one third of Gen Z shoppers and 34% of millennial shoppers who have student loan debt said they planned to reduce or skip a payment to afford holiday expenses.

Shopping Peer Pressure?

Why do we spend more than we plan, even when we know we shouldn’t?

Societal pressure and expectations can make curbing your holiday spending hard, said Alexander Smith, an associate professor in behavioral economics at Worcester Polytechnic Institute.

“When you’re spending on giving to other people or spending to do things with other people, it makes it really hard to hold back,” said Smith.

But the high costs of living are squeezing people’s budgets and causing some to evaluate their holiday spending carefully, Smith told USA TODAY.

It’s Time for an Uncomfortable Conversation

Overall, 35% of respondents said they planned to skip traditions due to high costs this holiday season, including 28% who are going to skip dining out and 22% who are going to cut back on holiday vacations.

And 41% of respondents said they planned to proactively have a conversation with their friends and family about what they can afford this holiday season, according to a new study from Intuit Credit Karma.

So how do you explain to friends and family that you want to spread some holiday cheer but not break your budget while doing it?

“In our society, we’re not socialized to be comfortable talking about money, so it’s a challenging thing for many people,” Smith said.

But people need to be proactive about initiating those discussions, he said. And transparency about your circumstances is a good way to start.

“Be open and honest about the financial challenges being faced right now,” he said.

Even though it’s hard to be vulnerable about a money challenge, “it’s helpful because it creates a shared understanding about what the challenges are and that has the potential to create some sympathy and perhaps empathy about the realities being faced by people today,” Smith said.

Rather than having a full family or friends sit down, it might be helpful to first talk about your need to trim spending with one or two people.

Oftentimes, Alev said, one party or the other “breathes a sigh of relief and says ‘Oh, I’m feeling that crunch, too.’ … If you find that you’re in similar situations, then you get a little bit of support and maybe some encouragement to then later approach the larger group.”

Set a Holiday Budget to Avoid Overspending

Shoppers also need to come up with a realistic budget for themselves, Smith said.

Without a budget, “you can really lose track throughout the season and a lot of little purchases… can really add up to more than you thought you were going to spend,” said Alev.

Holiday budgets should include more than just gifts, but other ways you will be spending money during the season, such as travel, hosting or events, Alev said.

“It’s also important to leave a little bit of wiggle room for unexpected expenses,” she said. “Maybe it’s a higher than expected utility bill for the Christmas lights or an unexpected car repair.”

Find Other Types of Gifts

Trimming spending doesn’t have to dim the holiday spirit.

“I tend to suggest to people that they try some kind of moderation,” said Smith, who likened his budget and gifting advice to exercise or dieting. “Instead of going from all to nothing, is there some kind of compromise in between that might work for everyone.”

Consider personalizing a gift that isn’t as expensive, but is unique or consider forgoing gifts and doing a group activity that everyone enjoys, said Smith.

Some families also opt for alternatives such as Thriftmas, buying only second-hand gifts.

Gift-Giving Doesn’t Have to Be Equal

Smith said it’s also important to acknowledge that not everyone is in the same boat financially. Some family members may be willing and able to spend the same or more while others want to cut back on gift-giving.

Families can fashion their own approach. You may want to take the grown ups and teenagers off the shopping list and just buy gifts for younger kids. Or older generations may take on more of the hosting responsibilities for holiday events so younger relatives do not have to spend, he said.

If someone gave you a nice gift last year, it can be tempting to feel the pressure to reciprocate, “even if I need to go into debt,” said Alev.

But “if it’s someone who is a trusted family (member) or friend, they want what’s best for you,” she said.

Betty Lin-Fisher is a consumer reporter for USA TODAY. Reach her at [email protected] or follow her on X, Facebook or Instagram @blinfisher and @blinfisher.bsky.social on Bluesky. Sign up for our free The Daily Money newsletter, which breaks down complex consumer and financial news. Subscribe here.

Reporting by Betty Lin-Fisher, USA TODAY. USA TODAY Network via Reuters Connect.

 

Upgrade to an ad-free experience

As a newsletter subscriber, you're already part of the family. Members enjoy distraction-free reading, PDF downloads, and exclusive perks.

No ads • PDF downloads • 2 free eBooks • Email us questions
Learn more about membership benefits •