For most of us, understanding one retirement income system is hassle enough for a lifetime. But a new report examined the systems of 47 countries, which collectively cover two-thirds of the world’s population.
The Mercer CFA Institute Global Pension Index identifies the best pension systems on Earth — both public and private. For each country, it considers factors related to adequacy of income, long-term sustainability of benefits and the integrity and cost management of each program.
Sorry to say you won’t see the United States anywhere near the top of this list — it earned the middling rank of No. 22, with an overall grade of C+.
According to Mercer, a C+ grade represents “a system that has some good features, but also has major risks and/or shortcomings that should be addressed; without these improvements, its efficacy and/or long-term sustainability can be questioned.”
Following is a look at the best of the best — countries that Mercer gave a grade of B or better.
1. Netherlands
Overall pension index score: 85 out of 100 possible points
Pension index grade: A
The Dutch retirement plan includes a flat-rate public pension and what Mercer calls a “quasi-mandatory” occupational pension.
Unlike America’s Social Security benefits, the Dutch public pension cannot be delayed past full retirement age. But pensioners are allowed to continue working while collecting benefits, and some of the work pensions “allow a member to withdraw a pension and continue to work with the same employer,” according to the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD).
2. Iceland
Overall pension index score: 83.5 out of 100 possible points
Pension index grade: A
Iceland’s system tackles retirement from several angles — it includes a means-tested state pension and supplemental pension; work-based pensions that both employers and employees are required to participate in; and voluntary personal retirement savings.
The normal pension age in Iceland is 67, and employers are required to pay at least twice as much as employees do into the occupational pensions.
3. Denmark
Overall pension index score: 81.3 out of 100 possible points
Pension index grade: A
Denmark makes Mercer’s top grade thanks to its offering of a public pension, means-tested supplementary benefits and defined contribution work plans. About 90% of the workforce is covered by the latter type of plan, with self-employed workers having the option to create their own.
4. Israel
Overall pension index score: 80.8 out of 100 possible points
Pension index grade: A
Israel requires employers and employees to contribute to private pensions while also offering a universal state pension and a means-tested supplemental pension.
The state pension is available to men at age 67 and to women at age 62.
5. Australia
Overall pension index score: 77.3 out of 100 possible points
Pension index grade: B+
Down Under, employers are required to pay into retirement plans to a certain degree, and they and their employees can make additional voluntary contributions. There’s also a means-tested public pension.
7. Singapore
Overall pension index score: 76.3 out of 100 possible points
Pension index grade: B+
Singapore’s system allows for some public benefits to be withdrawn by workers at any time for certain housing and medical expenses, but others are specifically for retirement.
8. Norway
Overall pension index score: 74.4 out of 100 possible points
Pension index grade: B
Norway, the top-ranking “B” grade, has a social security system as well as mandatory work plans. People who’ve lived in Norway for at least five years between ages 16 and 66 are entitled to some benefits.
9. Sweden
Overall pension index score: 74 out of 100 possible points
Pension index grade: B
Sweden is in the middle of moving “from a pay-as-you-go system to a funded approach,” Mercer says. It is also gradually raising the minimum age for taking benefits from earnings-related national pensions to 64 by 2026.
10. United Kingdom
Overall pension index score: 73 out of 100 possible points
Pension index grade: B
The U.K. approach requires auto-enrollment in work pension schemes with minimum contributions of 8%, but employees are allowed to opt out. There is also a state pension that is currently available from age 66.
11. Switzerland
Overall pension index score: 72 out of 100 possible points
Pension index grade: B
Retirement funds here accumulate in public, work and voluntary personal plans and, like Swiss cheddar, are kept until nicely aged — 65 for men, 64 for women.
12. Canada (tie)
Overall pension index score: 70.2 out of 100 possible points
Pension index grade: B
Canadians enjoy a sweet-as-maple-syrup flat-rate pension with a means-tested supplement, a separate pension based on lifetime earnings, and voluntary work-related and individual retirement saving plans. A reduced benefit is available from age 60, with the full retirement age sitting at 65 and — as in the U.S. — the option to claim larger benefits up through age 70.
12. Ireland (tie)
Overall pension index score: 70.2 out of 100 possible points
Pension index grade: B
These lucky folks receive a flat rate social security pension or a means-tested benefit if they didn’t make sufficient contributions in their working years. There are also optional work and personal pension plans.
14. Chile
Overall pension index score: 69.9 out of 100 possible points
Pension index grade: B
Chileans benefit from a means-tested social assistance program, mandatory employee contributions and an option for voluntary contributions. Mercer says its grade could be bumped up with a higher pension age for women (currently 60 to men’s 65) and more support for the poorest seniors.
15. Uruguay
Overall pension index score: 68.9 out of 100 possible points
Pension index grade: B
Uruguay has a pay-as-you-go social security system and private pensions, both funded by mandatory contributions from employers and employees. Because of updated data, Uruguay’s latest annual score dipped slightly.
16. Belgium
Overall pension index score: 68.6 out of 100 possible points
Pension index grade: B
Belgium’s current retirement age is 65 for both men and women, but it will rise to 66 in 2025 and to 67 in 2030. Mercer says Belgium needs a minimum mandatory contribution to bump up its score.
17. New Zealand
Overall pension index score: 68.3 out of 100 possible points
Pension index grade: B
New Zealanders enjoy a flat-rate public pension and can also participate in a voluntary system introduced in 2007 called KiwiSaver, which is funded by employers, employees and the government alike.
18. Portugal
Overall pension index score: 67.4 out of 100 possible points
Pension index grade: B
Portugal has a public pension based on career earnings and a means-tested safety net. “There are also voluntary personal and occupational pension schemes, but coverage is low,” Mercer says.
19. Germany
Overall pension index score: 66.8 out of 100 possible points
Pension index grade: B
A pay-as-you-go system is supplemented by a means-tested safety net and widely available private employer plans in Germany. Similar to American Social Security, Germans have the option of taking an early benefit at a permanent deduction, or delaying beyond full retirement age for a higher one.
Add a Comment
Our Policy: We welcome relevant and respectful comments in order to foster healthy and informative discussions. All other comments may be removed. Comments with links are automatically held for moderation.