Ask Stacy: How Can My Car Insurance Go up Like This?

Photo (cc) by JaviC

Here’s an email I recently received: Have you had a similar experience?

Hi Stacy,
Have you written any articles about the latest auto insurance industry scam? I have been with [redacted] for 19 years–three or four years ago a speeding ticket (79 in a 65mph zone) and in the last year two fender benders backing out of a parking space. As expected my rates went up $45/month. While dealing with [redacted] I noticed that my ex husband had never been removed from the policy. I have been divorced for 15 years.

When I requested that his name be removed, I was hit with another $55/month increase. It seems that I am a single divorced woman and that makes me a higher risk?!! Where is that written in the insurance rules? First, I have tried to fight it completely unsuccessfully then I started realizing that many women have run into this type of discrimination. Any advice? I really want this scam to be brought out to the state insurance commissioners. At this time, they are not listening.

Thanks,
Linda

Here’s your answer, Linda!

Suppose you and I got together and started a car insurance company. Even before we start issuing policies and taking in premiums, we’re going to hire people called actuaries to look for patterns and assess risk. Do teenage boys have accidents more often? Divorced women? Drunk people? People with lower credit scores? Red-headed, left-handed people of Irish decent? It’s the actuary’s job to study the numbers and report their findings to us.

Our goal is take in as much money in premiums as possible and pay out as little as possible in claims. So it behooves us to find out if certain categories of customers are more likely to have accidents than others. If we can find a pattern that suggests one group is more likely to submit claims than another, we charge them more. And with certain exceptions, there are no rules that say we can’t.

This is how insurance works. But while some categories of high-risk drivers are obvious – those with a drunk driving conviction, for example – others aren’t. Why should people with low credit scores be more likely to wreck their cars? Why should a divorced woman like Linda be a higher risk than one still married? The insurance company doesn’t have to explain it, nor do they care. They look at the data, and if the data suggests single women cost more to insure than married women, they’re simply going to charge them more.

But isn’t that discrimination? No. Discrimination is treating people differently arbitrarily. In other words, charging people of a certain sex, race, or religion differently for subjective, rather than objective, reasons. If I pay more for life insurance than Linda does because the CEO of an insurance company hates men, that’s discrimination. But if the insurance company can prove that men are statistically more likely to die earlier than women, charging me more than Linda isn’t discrimination, it’s good business.

So what’s Linda to do? You probably already know the answer. Shop. That’s why we have an insurance shopping tool and why Linda – and you – should use it. Because not all insurance companies are the same. Due to her recent fender-benders, Linda’s company may no longer want her business. Rather than simply canceling her coverage, however, they’re going to jack up her rates and see if she’ll put up with it.

But there may be another insurance company out there that’s trying to grow its client base and wants Linda’s business despite her accidents. There may be companies that have looked at their data and drawn the conclusion that women who have been divorced for 15 years drive just as safely as those that are still married. The only way to find out is shop.

If Linda finds that all insurance companies are as inflexible as her current provider, she should wait until her tickets and accidents fall off her record – typically three years – and try again. But if you’re paying more than you think you should for insurance or anything else, the answer isn’t to get mad. It’s to get even by taking your business elsewhere.

Got more money questions? Browse lots more Ask Stacy answers here.

Disclosure: The information you read here is always objective. However, we sometimes receive compensation when you click links within our stories.

Read Next
7 Unexpected Perks of Downsizing as a Retiree
7 Unexpected Perks of Downsizing as a Retiree

Downsizing your home offers many benefits, including some you may not have anticipated.

7 Things You Should Buy at Estate Sales
7 Things You Should Buy at Estate Sales

Here’s what an experienced estate sale shopper considers a great find.

Have You Heard of This Best Place to Retire in 2020?
Have You Heard of This Best Place to Retire in 2020?

The best place to retire in America is one you likely are not familiar with.

5 Surveys For Money Sites To Get Paid For Your Opinion
5 Surveys For Money Sites To Get Paid For Your Opinion

Yes, you can earn extra cash by taking online surveys. But some websites are better than others for this. Here are a few of our favorites.

26 Work-From-Home Jobs That Pay $100,000
26 Work-From-Home Jobs That Pay $100,000

These lucrative gigs let you work in your slippers.

View this page without ads

Help us produce more money-saving articles and videos by subscribing to a membership.

Get Started

Most Popular
9 Things You’ll Never See at Costco Again
9 Things You’ll Never See at Costco Again

The warehouse store offers an enormous selection, but these products aren’t coming back.

11 Things Retirees Should Always Buy at Costco
11 Things Retirees Should Always Buy at Costco

This leader in bulk shopping is a great place to find discounts in the fixed-income years.

Over 50? The CDC Says You Need These 4 Vaccines
Over 50? The CDC Says You Need These 4 Vaccines

Fall is the time to schedule vaccines that can keep you healthy — and even save your life.

11 Senior Discounts for Anyone Age 55 or Older
11 Senior Discounts for Anyone Age 55 or Older

There is no need to wait until you’re 65 to take advantage of so-called “senior” discounts.

11 Household Items That Go Bad — or Become Dangerous
11 Household Items That Go Bad — or Become Dangerous

When you get the impulse to stockpile these everyday items, pay close attention to their expiration dates.

8 Things You Can Get for Free at Pharmacies
8 Things You Can Get for Free at Pharmacies

In this age of higher-priced drugs and complex health care systems, a trip to the pharmacy can spark worry. Freebies sure do help.

These Are the 4 Best Medicare Advantage Plans for 2020
These Are the 4 Best Medicare Advantage Plans for 2020

Medicare Advantage customers themselves rate these plans highest.

7 Ways to Boost Your Credit Score Fast
7 Ways to Boost Your Credit Score Fast

Your financial security might soon depend upon the strength of your credit score.

The 10 Most Commonly Stolen Vehicles in America
The 10 Most Commonly Stolen Vehicles in America

A new model parks atop the list of vehicles that thieves love to pilfer.

19 High-Paying Jobs You Can Get With a 2-Year Degree
19 High-Paying Jobs You Can Get With a 2-Year Degree

These jobs pay more than the typical job in the U.S. — and no bachelor’s degree is required.

5 Ways to Get Amazon Prime for Free
5 Ways to Get Amazon Prime for Free

Hesitant to drop $119 a year on an Amazon Prime membership? Here’s how to get it for free.

10 Reasons Why You Should Actually Retire at 62
10 Reasons Why You Should Actually Retire at 62

If you can, here are several good reasons to retire earlier than we’re told to.

3 Ways to Get Microsoft Office for Free
3 Ways to Get Microsoft Office for Free

With a little ingenuity, you can cut Office costs to zero.

26 States That Do Not Tax Social Security Income
26 States That Do Not Tax Social Security Income

These states won’t tax any of your Social Security income — and in some cases, other types of retirement income.

14 Things That Are ‘Free’ With Medicare
14 Things That Are ‘Free’ With Medicare

These services could save you money and help prevent costly health problems.

5 Keys to Making Your Car Last for 200,000 Miles
5 Keys to Making Your Car Last for 200,000 Miles

Pushing your car to 200,000 miles — and beyond — can save you piles of cash. Here’s how to get there.

5 Things That Make Life More Meaningful for Retirees
5 Things That Make Life More Meaningful for Retirees

Retirees agree: These are the things that give them purpose and fulfillment in their golden years.

15 Amazon Purchases That We Are Loving Right Now
15 Amazon Purchases That We Are Loving Right Now

These practical products make everyday life a little easier.

10 Things You Should Never Do With Bleach
10 Things You Should Never Do With Bleach

Does the pandemic have you reaching for bleach more than ever before? Learn the ins and outs of using this powerful disinfectant.

View More Articles

View this page without ads

Help us produce more money-saving articles and videos by subscribing to a membership.

Get Started

Add a Comment

Our Policy: We welcome relevant and respectful comments in order to foster healthy and informative discussions. All other comments may be removed. Comments with links are automatically held for moderation.