They Planned to Retire With $1.2 Million at 65. But at 60, They Divorced and Sold Their Home. A Year Later, Their Lives Were Very Different.

Older couple at home, fighting and unhappy.
PeopleImages / Shutterstock.com

The rise in late-life divorce means more Americans enter their 60s with a very different future than the one they expected.

The financial impact is unavoidable. A shared retirement fund becomes two smaller ones. A single home becomes an asset that must be sold or divided. A plan built for two becomes something neither spouse can rely on anymore.

Let’s assume Mark and Elaine planned to retire on $1.2 million. After an amicable divorce at 60, each faced retirement on $600,000 plus the proceeds of the sale of their house.

Their story reflects a situation many Americans face today: a clean split that still forces a complete rethinking of how to live, where to live, and how long their savings will last.

A year later, Mark and Elaine were pleased to have remained friendly. Both believed that with careful planning, their $600,000 nest eggs could still support retirements they would be happy with. Their situations were not identical, but they were stable.

But life took a different turn for Mark.

The best laid plans may not be enough

For twelve months after finalizing the divorce, home sale and financial settlement, all was well.

Elaine found work in her area of expertise, even after a long career gap, and enjoyed steady part-time hours. Mark stayed in his full-time role, focused on maintaining his income and avoiding early withdrawals from savings.

Then, at 61, Mark suffered a heart attack.

Mark survived and recovered well enough to live independently, but the heart attack reshaped his daily life. He tired easily, had trouble with long workdays, and faced regular medical appointments and new prescriptions.

His doctor approved a phased return to work, and his employer supported him at every step. They extended his medical leave, helped him access short-term disability payments, and offered a flexible schedule with remote workdays.

Despite the support, Mark struggled. Even with reduced hours, he could not sustain the pace of his former role. Some days, he managed only a few hours before exhaustion set in. His responsibilities required consistent output that he could no longer guarantee.

After several discussions, Mark and his employer agreed on a voluntary separation. The company offered a modest severance package and extended benefits for a brief period.

He now had to confront the possibility of claiming Social Security at 62, years earlier than he had intended.

Elaine, meanwhile, was going from strength to strength. She was healthy and fit. Her workload was flexible. Her new home suited her lifestyle, and her savings remained largely untouched. Working longer allowed her to delay Social Security benefits withdrawals and strengthen her financial position.

A level starting point is only the beginning

The home Mark purchased after the divorce suddenly worked against him. He had used all the proceeds from the sale of the family home and purchased a smaller version in the same area.

It had stairs he now struggled with, maintenance he could not manage, and a location that required more driving than his doctor recommended. Renovations were expensive. Moving again meant another round of transaction costs.

With limited income and rising medical bills, none of the options felt easy. Selling would produce cash but reduce stability. Renovating would drain savings he now needed for care. Staying put risked safety and stress.

Elaine’s situation remained simpler. She had moved into a comfortable ground-floor apartment and her downsized home required little upkeep. She lived near services and family, and rarely needed to drive. Nothing in her environment demanded costly change.

The endgame may be starkly different

Mark’s expenses began to rise in ways he never expected. Cardiac rehabilitation, follow-up testing, higher insurance costs, and new prescriptions strained his monthly budget

His severance helped briefly, but it did not replace a steady income. He found part-time contract work that brought in some earnings, but not enough to avoid dipping into savings.

Elaine, by contrast, continued to work and was able to postpone any major withdrawals. Her savings stayed intact, and her benefits remained stable through her employer. Her lifestyle changed little.

Both had begun with $600,000. Mark now faced the risk of running out of money. Elaine maintained confidence in her long-term plans.

Planning for the unexpected

The contrast between Elaine and Mark’s retirement steps reflects a reality many older adults face after a gray divorce. Even when the split is fair and amicable, unexpected health events can widen the financial gap almost immediately. It is virtually impossible to plan for every eventuality, and luck — or bad luck — can play its part.

However, there are practical lessons for older divorcees:

  • Schedule a full health review. Identifying risks early can help you plan smarter and avoid costly surprises as you age. Life Line Screening reveals hidden risks so you can act early. Book a screening today.
  • Reevaluate your insurance coverage. Premiums, deductibles and out-of-pocket costs rise quickly in your 60s, and a single event can dramatically increase annual expenses.
  • Avoid tying up all your cash in a new home. Keep enough liquid savings to handle medical costs, income changes, or an unexpected move.
  • Choose a property that can support aging in place. Ground-floor living, minimal stairs, and low maintenance reduce the risk of costly moves later.
  • Keep working while you can and keep skills current. Continued employment provides income, benefits, and protection against early withdrawals.
  • Stress-test your retirement plan for health shocks. Model what happens if income drops, insurance changes, or major out-of-pocket costs hit unexpectedly.
  • Review Social Security timing with new assumptions. Delaying benefits may create stability for one spouse, but early claiming may be necessary for another.

Mark and Elaine began their new lives with equal resources and reasonable expectations. They made responsible choices and worked through their separation without conflict. Yet an unexpected medical event changed Mark’s future.

Their story shows that retirement planning after divorce requires more than dividing assets evenly. It requires preparing for the uneven ways life unfolds.

Sources

Pew Research Center; Kaiser Family Foundation; Federal Reserve; Employee Benefit Research Institute; American Heart Association

 

Upgrade to an ad-free experience

As a newsletter subscriber, you're already part of the family. Members enjoy distraction-free reading, PDF downloads, and exclusive perks.

No ads • PDF downloads • 2 free eBooks • Email us questions
Learn more about membership benefits •