Who Is Winning the Spoils of Economic Recovery? The Rich, and Robots

The U.S. economy, as so many of life’s big issues, has a blind-man-and-elephant problem. If you have a good job or you just got a raise, you think America has rebounded nicely. If you are still struggling to replace income you lost during the Great Recession, you think things stink. Who’s to say either is wrong?

Well, I am. Let’s all agree on terms first. A healthy, growing middle class means the economy is back on solid footing, right?

America is growing all right, but the middle class isn’t. Almost all of the middle class feels restless, a phenomenon I’m chronicling in The Restless Project. In fact, new research I will discuss below shows that in many places, most of the income growth since 2012 has gone to America’s 1 percent. In 14 states, ALL the income growth went to America’s richest.

This is not a new phenomenon. It began in the 1980s. Recessions have merely helped accelerate it. So did technology. And while billionaire Peter Thiel laid out an impassioned defense of robots this week (easy for him), there is plenty of evidence that very soon, robots will eliminate middle-class jobs and shove potentially millions of Americans into low-wage work.

Barbell economy

Try as you might to retrain and retrain and retrain, most of you won’t be able to keep up with robots in the future. Science fiction warns us that artificial intelligence will arrive and force us into a robot war, as in “The Matrix.” In reality, robots won’t have to fight us on a battlefield. They’ll just take our jobs.

Get used to the word barbell, because you’re going to hear it a lot. In the barbell economy, we’ll have lots of folks becoming millionaires, and lots of overqualified folks stuck in dead-end jobs that don’t pay enough. Another term for this is job polarization, as used by David Autor of MIT.

But first, who’s “winning” the recovery?The Economic Policy Institute issued a report last week with this shocking claim: Not only has the 1 percent captured 95 percent of the income growth from 2009 to 2012, but in 39 states, the 1 percent captured between half and all income growth.

And here’s a list you don’t want to be on: the states in which all income growth between 2009 and 2012 accrued to the top 1 percent. It includes Delaware, Florida, Missouri, South Carolina, North Carolina, Connecticut, Washington, Louisiana, California, Virginia, Pennsylvania, Idaho, Massachusetts, Colorado, New York, Rhode Island and Nevada.

“In the next decade, something must give,” the report’s authors conclude. “Either America must accept that the American Dream of widespread economic mobility is dead, or new policies must emerge that will begin to restore broadly shared prosperity.”

More jobs, if you can afford to work for the wage

How can this be? Much of it can be explained by the mixed bag that is our employment recovery. Yes, unemployment is down drastically since the recession. But no, wages haven’t climbed with them. That’s because all jobs aren’t created equal. Endless stories have described the terrible reality that many workers who lost middle-class jobs have returned to the workforce earning much less. In California, for example, almost all new jobs are low-wage jobs. Those $15-to-$30-an-hour jobs have been replaced by minimum wage jobs. (Minimum wage in California is $9 an hour.)

This is common in recoveries. An examination of victims from the 1980s recession in Pennsylvania found that, even six years after their layoff, displaced workers were still earning on average 25 percent less. They also tended to die younger; something else we can expect from this most recent recession. Know someone who had to take a pay cut and a job they’re wildly overqualified for, post-recession? Of course you do.

Some of this is the result of traditional wage pressures that persist after a recession, as the economy processes a worker surplus. As we get closer to something like full employment, wage pressure will rise. Thankfully, in the most recent jobs report, there was an indication that wages are rising.

But about those robots. A troubling report out earlier this week from Boston Consulting claims that machines are poised and ready to disrupt workers in plenty of middle-class professions. Robots will cut labor costs by 22 percent in the United States, the report says. Even more ominous, robots are getting cheaper. The cost of owning and operating a robotic spot welder, for example, has tumbled from $182,000 in 2005 to $133,000 last year, according to the Associated Press. That’s enough to keep you up at night.

Thiel and other wide-eyed optimists argue that robots will take mundane jobs, leaving workers to pursue higher, more gratifying pursuits. Who wanted to be a tollbooth collector anyway, right? Who sheds a tear when EZPass displaces another government worker, right? (Other than that worker and her/his family).

The real fallacy is the faith, shocking among folks who otherwise demand science, that this magical class of even better jobs will appear. Just because farmers were able to move to cities and find good jobs 100 years ago doesn’t mean middle-class workers replaced by robots will find good jobs in this decade. The reality will be much more mixed, as described with great thoughtfulness in this Farhad Manjoo story on Slate.

Minimum wage for robots?

Certainly, some people will find a way to make money with robots. But it’s easy to imagine that taxi drivers replaced by robot drivers will end up in intense, face-to-face, plentiful-but-lower-paying jobs such as elderly health care. As robots become intelligent enough to remove the human element from good-enough jobs such as security guards, reporters (yes, robots are writing AP stories now) and even lawyers, it’s foolhardy to imagine a little retraining will turn all these workers into mini-entrepreneurs.

It’s easy to imagine that, as in the economic recovery today, the 1 percent will reap the benefit from lower wage costs and many in the middle class will be pushed downward. That’s the barbell: folks will be pushed to either end of the economic ladder, with fewer in between.

Boston Consulting says robots can be operated for $4 an hour. Their health care is a lot cheaper, too. Think underpaid Chinese workers are the biggest menace to American jobs? Just wait.I don’t recommend violence against machines as a solution. The problem isn’t unsolvable. It’s a mixed bag. There will be winners and losers. The key is to make sure the spoils of the transition are more reasonably distributed. Workers need to be paid a real living wage, not a farcical minimum wage.

Everything possible should be done to make workers more mobile, including radical concepts such as putting in place completely portable health care and rules that make both training and moving easier. Collective bargaining needs to be restored and strengthened. Today’s income inequality is a great time to have this discussion, before tomorrow’s even bigger problems arise.

A country where all the gains go to the 1 percent is not a country with a healthy middle class. There are good reasons to be scared that lingering impacts of the Great Recession and coming cosmic leaps in technology will polarize these groups even more. It’s in everyone’s interest to nurture the middle class and spread the wealth around. Otherwise, as zillionaire Nick Hanauer has elegantly said, even the 1 percent will have a lot to lose sleep over.

Click to learn about The Restless Project
Click to learn about The Restless Project

Follow The Restless Project: Sign up for Bob Sullivan’s free email newsletter.

Disclosure: The information you read here is always objective. However, we sometimes receive compensation when you click links within our stories.

Read Next
Why Cutting the Cord Can Be Confusing — and How to Decide If It’s for You
Why Cutting the Cord Can Be Confusing — and How to Decide If It’s for You

Streaming TV might sound like the antidote to sky-high cable bills, but cutting the cord is easier said than done.

Beware These 5 Common Work-From-Home Scams
Beware These 5 Common Work-From-Home Scams

You can spot scammers and con artists with a little know-how.

10 Products That Upgrade Your Home for Less Than $45
10 Products That Upgrade Your Home for Less Than $45

Make a fresh start with these affordable Amazon buys.

26 Work-From-Home Jobs That Pay $100,000
26 Work-From-Home Jobs That Pay $100,000

These lucrative gigs let you work in your slippers.

7 Kitchen Gadgets That Make Healthy Cooking a Breeze
7 Kitchen Gadgets That Make Healthy Cooking a Breeze

These small appliances and cooking aids make healthy eating easy — and they’re all available on Amazon.

View this page without ads

Help us produce more money-saving articles and videos by subscribing to a membership.

Get Started

Most Popular
11 Things Retirees Should Always Buy at Costco
11 Things Retirees Should Always Buy at Costco

This leader in bulk shopping is a great place to find discounts in the fixed-income years.

Over 50? The CDC Says You Need These 4 Vaccines
Over 50? The CDC Says You Need These 4 Vaccines

Fall is the time to schedule vaccines that can keep you healthy — and even save your life.

9 Things You’ll Never See at Costco Again
9 Things You’ll Never See at Costco Again

The warehouse store offers an enormous selection, but these products aren’t coming back.

11 Senior Discounts for Anyone Age 55 or Older
11 Senior Discounts for Anyone Age 55 or Older

There is no need to wait until you’re 65 to take advantage of so-called “senior” discounts.

8 Things You Can Get for Free at Pharmacies
8 Things You Can Get for Free at Pharmacies

In this age of higher-priced drugs and complex health care systems, a trip to the pharmacy can spark worry. Freebies sure do help.

These Are the 4 Best Medicare Advantage Plans for 2020
These Are the 4 Best Medicare Advantage Plans for 2020

Medicare Advantage customers themselves rate these plans highest.

The 10 Most Commonly Stolen Vehicles in America
The 10 Most Commonly Stolen Vehicles in America

A new model parks atop the list of vehicles that thieves love to pilfer.

7 Ways to Boost Your Credit Score Fast
7 Ways to Boost Your Credit Score Fast

Your financial security might soon depend upon the strength of your credit score.

11 Household Items That Go Bad — or Become Dangerous
11 Household Items That Go Bad — or Become Dangerous

When you get the impulse to stockpile these everyday items, pay close attention to their expiration dates.

19 High-Paying Jobs You Can Get With a 2-Year Degree
19 High-Paying Jobs You Can Get With a 2-Year Degree

These jobs pay more than the typical job in the U.S. — and no bachelor’s degree is required.

5 Ways to Get Amazon Prime for Free
5 Ways to Get Amazon Prime for Free

Hesitant to drop $119 a year on an Amazon Prime membership? Here’s how to get it for free.

10 Reasons Why You Should Actually Retire at 62
10 Reasons Why You Should Actually Retire at 62

If you can, here are several good reasons to retire earlier than we’re told to.

3 Ways to Get Microsoft Office for Free
3 Ways to Get Microsoft Office for Free

With a little ingenuity, you can cut Office costs to zero.

14 Things That Are ‘Free’ With Medicare
14 Things That Are ‘Free’ With Medicare

These services could save you money and help prevent costly health problems.

5 Keys to Making Your Car Last for 200,000 Miles
5 Keys to Making Your Car Last for 200,000 Miles

Pushing your car to 200,000 miles — and beyond — can save you piles of cash. Here’s how to get there.

26 States That Do Not Tax Social Security Income
26 States That Do Not Tax Social Security Income

These states won’t tax any of your Social Security income — and in some cases, other types of retirement income.

5 Things That Make Life More Meaningful for Retirees
5 Things That Make Life More Meaningful for Retirees

Retirees agree: These are the things that give them purpose and fulfillment in their golden years.

10 Things You Should Never Do With Bleach
10 Things You Should Never Do With Bleach

Does the pandemic have you reaching for bleach more than ever before? Learn the ins and outs of using this powerful disinfectant.

15 Amazon Purchases That We Are Loving Right Now
15 Amazon Purchases That We Are Loving Right Now

These practical products make everyday life a little easier.

View More Articles

View this page without ads

Help us produce more money-saving articles and videos by subscribing to a membership.

Get Started

Add a Comment

Our Policy: We welcome relevant and respectful comments in order to foster healthy and informative discussions. All other comments may be removed. Comments with links are automatically held for moderation.