4 Car Insurers That Might Raise Rates Even When the Accident Wasn’t Your Fault

Advertising Disclosure: When you buy something by clicking links on our site, we may earn a small commission, but it never affects the products or services we recommend.

Lisa S. / Shutterstock.com

Pop quiz: Can your car insurance company raise your rate after you get into an accident that wasn’t your fault?

Unless you live in states such as California or Oklahoma — where this practice is prohibited by consumer protections — the answer is “yes,” according to the Consumer Federation of America (CFA).

The nonprofit organization recently studied this topic by analyzing premium quotes from five of the nation’s largest car insurance companies. It found that four of those companies have raised premiums after not-at-fault accidents at least some of the time.

  1. Progressive: Average premium increase of 16.6 percent for not-at-fault accidents (excluding California and Oklahoma)
  2. Geico: 14.1 percent
  3. Farmers: 11.1 percent
  4. Allstate: 4.8 percent

The fifth company, State Farm, never increased premiums after not-at-fault accidents.

How much your premium stands to increase after this type of accident also varies depending on where you live and how much you make, the CFA found.

For its study, the CFA analyzed quotes from 10 cities — and found that the average premium hike after a not-at-fault accident varied from $0 to $401:

  1. Queens, New York City: Average premium increase of $401 for not-at-fault accidents
  2. Baltimore: $258
  3. Minneapolis: $213
  4. Jacksonville, Florida: $132
  5. Kansas City: $123
  6. Jersey City, New Jersey: $104
  7. Chicago: $98
  8. Atlanta: $60

The other two cities, Los Angeles and Oklahoma City, saw no increase because such a move is prohibited in their respective states.

To determine how different income levels affect premium increases, CFA got quotes for two hypothetical drivers. Both were 30-year-old women who had been licensed for 14 years and drove a 2006 Toyota Camry for a total of 10,000 miles per year. They also had the same address. Their only differences were socioeconomic.

Here’s what CFA found:

  • Higher-income drivers: Average premium increase of $78, an average penalty of 6.6 percent, after not-at-fault accidents
  • Moderate-income drivers: $208, 9.6 percent

If you’re in the market for new car insurance, check out the information in our Solutions Center.

What do you make of this news? Sound off below or over on our Facebook page.

Get smarter with your money!

Want the best money-news and tips to help you make more and spend less? Then sign up for the free Money Talks Newsletter to receive daily updates of personal finance news and advice, delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for our free newsletter today.