Don’t cross me
In 2012, Orman started her own prepaid debit card. It lasted a couple of years, then was taken off the market.
To most personal finance pros, prepaid cards are controversial, primarily because of the fees they charge. Thus, the idea of a personal finance expert following in the footsteps of celebrity prepaid card creators like the Kardashians and Russell Simmons could seem questionable.
Russell Simmons has a card. It’s bad. The Kardashians created a “kard” in this market. It was bad too. So bad, that it was run out of town. Who’s up for another celebrity-branded prepaid card? This time it’s not just a celebrity. It’s the self-proclaimed “Most Trusted Personal Finance Expert” in America today, Suze Orman. She just released The Approved Card. I like Suze, but I don’t like that she has created this card and is marketing it in this way.
Here’s how Suze responded when someone named Briana tweeted a link to Phil’s article:
Money Talks News / Money Talks News
While Suze may not have agreed with Phil’s arguments, they were perfectly legitimate. He’s no idiot. And threatening a fan by saying “just keep following others and see where it gets you” simply sounds unhinged.
While this isn’t a great way to engage your enemies, it’s an awesome way to make new ones, and Orman did. The blogosphere exploded with articles from NerdWallet to FreeFromBroke condemning her tirade.
Orman later apologized.
Driving Miss Crazy
Suze Orman, like nearly every other personal finance adviser, isn’t a fan of buying cars new. From her Facebook page:
Remember, the minute a new car is driven off the lot, it loses 20% of its value; if you buy a new[er] used car, you won’t be paying for that.
Good, sound advice. But if you don’t think people should buy new cars, should you endorse them on TV, as she does in an Acura commercial?
One might argue that appearing in an ad for cars doesn’t compromise Orman’s objectivity or integrity. But as far as I’m concerned, the optics are bad: She’s willing to trade her credibility for cash.
I don’t know what it’s like to have a $30 million net worth, nor do I know the temptation of being approached for a national car ad. But I’d like to think that if I already had more money than I could spend, I’d turn down an ad that sent the wrong message to my audience. Hopefully one day I’ll have the opportunity to find out.
It’s not just Suze
Suze Orman has presumably helped many Americans feel more in control of their money, and I agree with the vast majority of the things I’ve heard her say over the years. But this article isn’t just about Suze Orman. It’s about you and where you can find advice you can trust.
It’s reasonable to assume that when you see someone on TV, or see their books on best-seller lists, you can trust their advice. Reasonable, but wrong. Being famous doesn’t make you smart. Oprah Winfrey claiming you’re an expert doesn’t make you one. Being rich doesn’t equate to being wise. Admitting to stupid mistakes doesn’t make them less stupid.
Here’s the bottom line: Read as much as you can from as many sources as you choose. But if you’re going to put your trust somewhere, put it first with those who have academic credentials, a long track record and a history of saying and doing things that are logical and successful.
I founded Money Talks News in 1991. I’m a CPA, and have also earned licenses in stocks, commodities, options principal, mutual funds, life insurance, securities supervisor and real estate. And I’ve forgotten more about personal finance than Suze Orman will ever learn.
Got any words of wisdom you can offer for this week’s Ask Stacy question? Share your knowledge and experiences on our Facebook page.
Got more money questions? Browse lots more Ask Stacy answers here.