Thanksgiving favorites like mashed potatoes and green bean casserole are mostly vegetables, right? Well, depending on how you cook them, nutritionists say most Thanksgiving staples aren’t that healthy.
Sure, there’s fruit such as cranberry sauce and vegetables in the stuffing, but it isn’t necessarily healthy depending on how it’s prepared, according to Lindsay Malone, a registered dietitian and instructor of nutrition at the School of Medicine at Case Western Reserve University in Cleveland, Ohio, and Briana Reamer, a registered dietitian nutritionist based in Chicago.
When you break it down, Thanksgiving is a lot more than turkey, vegetables and carbs.
Dietitians Rank the Least to Most Healthy Foods
Here’s what dietitians say is the least and most healthy food of the holiday.
1. Mac and cheese
It’s pretty much noodles, cheese and milk, filled with salt and saturated fats. In comparison, Reamer said it’s worse than mashed potatoes and gravy combined, which contain heavy amounts of saturated fat. You can make it a little healthier by using low-sodium cheeses, but, Reamer said, not many people eat mac and cheese with mozzarella. While it’s the unhealthiest part on the table, you can still have a little. Reamer recommended making half the plate vegetables with a spoonful of mac and cheese and stuffing.
2. Dinner rolls
There’s nothing wrong with a dinner roll, but if it’s rolls from a refrigerator case, Reamer said this bumps it up to the top of the list. Crescent rolls have sugar and artificial ingredients, and are likely topped with butter. If you’re looking for a healthier option, Reamer recommends whole grain dinner rolls. Even with a whole grain roll, it adds to the carbs already on your plate.
“I do believe there’s nothing wrong with having your dinner roll, but I want you to always consider: what are the carbohydrates that are already on the plate,” said Reamer.
3. Cranberry sauce
Cranberry sauce can be unhealthy depending on how you cook it: if it’s from a can, it’s very sugary, but if it’s made fresh, it’s much better for you.
From a can, it’s mostly sugar with a few grams of fiber and phytonutrients, according to Malone. Reamer said canned cranberry sauce is high in sugar and low in nutrients. For example, Ocean Spray Jellied Cranberry Sauce has over 20 grams of added sugar. If it’s cooked down and stewed, Malone said it would rank lower on the list, since there is only a little bit of sugar. Reamer said to use fresh cranberries, where you can get Vitamin C from it as well.
4. Stuffing
Stuffing incorporates vegetables like celery and onions, but it is based on a lot of white bread and is sometimes topped with creamed sauce and fat drippings, Reamer said. One way to make that healthier is to swap the white bread for whole grain.
5. Gravy
Gravy comes from the turkey, but it still isn’t the healthiest option. Malone said gravy doesn’t use the protein components of turkey, so it’s fat mixed with starch. You could make it healthier by not thickening it up and leaving it as is. It ranks toward the middle of the list since it has some amino acids and some “redeeming qualities,” according to Malone.
6. Green bean casserole
Green bean casserole is getting an “F” grade from Malone in nutritional value, but it’s ranked a bit healthier because it can be prepared differently. This is a sneakily unhealthy dish because there’s added butter and oil. The way the dish is normally made with canned green beans, canned soup and fried onions doesn’t add nutritional value, but it can be made differently. Instead, Malone recommended using fresh or frozen green beans and making your own soup to go on top of the dish that uses olive or avocado oil.
7. Mashed potatoes
Reamer said mashed potatoes aren’t that bad if they’re made plain or not topped with gravy. Potatoes are fairly healthy, with nutrients like Vitamin C, fiber and potassium, but once they get boiled into mashed potatoes, those healthy aspects get lost in butter and cream. Malone said mashed potatoes can be the unhealthiest because people add sticks of butter in them, bringing in a ton of saturated fat.
Where the Healthiest Choices Are
8. Vegetables
Vegetables are obviously good for you and one of the healthiest dishes to Malone. Baking, broiling and roasting root vegetables for the table still holds seasonal flavor with nutritional value. They don’t have to fit on the table, either. Malone said you can put out vegetables with a dip for people to snack on before the meal.
9. Turkey
Turkey is the healthiest dish at Thanksgiving. Malone said you’re getting mostly lean protein, and even if you get some dark meat and skin, which has slightly higher saturated fat content, it’s still fine.
“You’re getting a very good amount of protein that’s going to keep you full and satisfied, keep your blood sugar stable and probably prevent you from overeating,” said Malone.
Whether it’s healthy or not, Malone encourages people to enjoy the day and time with family, and eat when you want to eat, but try to make a balanced plate. That means a quarter protein, a quarter carbs and half vegetables. She also recommends waiting before going back for seconds to see if you’re still hungry without overdoing it.
Reporting by Maddie Rhodes, USA TODAY / USA TODAY
USA TODAY Network via Reuters Connect

Add a Comment