Is Basic Business Class Worth It? What to Know about the Newest Fare

USA TODAY Network / Reuters

Passport Check is USA TODAY’s weekly international travel briefing, helping you stay ahead of changing rules, trends, costs and opportunities around the world.

For many travelers, a basic economy ticket is like signing up for a no-frills flying experience. Now, the lowest-tier fare has made its way from the front of the aircraft to the first-class cabin.

Some U.S. airlines have recently introduced an entry-level option for their most premium cabins. It follows the same model of basic economy in which a passenger receives only the seat instead of the full package with seat selection, checked baggage and sometimes even a carry-on bag. A basic first-class ticket trades more restrictions and flexibility for a lower price.

At first, I was skeptical. I tend to stay away from basic fares simply based on how bare-bones they are. On United Airlines, a basic economy passenger isn’t allowed a carry-on bag, and if their personal item is too big to fit under the seat, it’ll cost $75 to gate check it. Since seat selection and a carry-on are must-haves for me when flying, it makes more financial sense to go straight for the standard tier. But that unbundling of perks requires an entirely different mental equation of trade-offs in business class, where travelers expect to pay for a more luxurious, seamless experience.

In July, Delta Air Lines added a basic tier to its Delta First, Delta Premium Select and Delta One cabins. These passengers get the same onboard experience as the classic and extra fares but with more restrictions, like no advance seat assignment or mileage earning.

“The ‘Basic’ option is ideally suited for customers who value the premium onboard experience, but place less importance on factors like advance seat assignment, the ability to change or cancel without a fee, complimentary or paid upgrades, or mileage earn,” states Delta’s website.

United Airlines also announced it would be launching a similar entry-level option this fall for its United First and United Business cabins, below its standard and flexible fares. Passengers have to pay for a seat selection and get only one checked bag instead of two.

In September, JetBlue revealed its new BlueFirst cabin, a first-class seating option on domestic routes expected to become available later this year. The airline also said it will overhaul its fare structure, introducing a basic tier for BlueFirst and its premium lie-flat seat option called Mint that will be more restrictive. American Airlines has yet to launch a basic tier for its most premium class.

Some may be wondering whether a basic first-class ticket is worth it, or whether the restrictions take away from the experience. After looking into it, I think there are some cases in which international travelers looking for that extra bit of comfort to get through long-haul flights would find basic first class beneficial.

Here’s what to know about the introduction of basic first class.

Why are airlines introducing basic first class fares?

By offering a cheaper first-class ticket, airlines are expanding the pool of travelers who are willing to splurge a little for some first-class perks but don’t need the full experience. Instead of Delta One, basic business passengers won’t receive access to the Delta One Lounge or check-in starting on Jan. 18, 2027. However, they still get Zone 1 boarding and the same three-course meal service and other onboard experiences.

“Offering both fares lets Delta and United attract someone who might otherwise book a cabin lower and still charge more to travelers who value that flexibility,” Derek Cann, flight expert at Going, told me in an email. For example, someone on a long-haul flight to Europe may want the lie-flat seat in business class but not mind passing up the other benefits, he added.

For international carriers, basic fares for premium cabins aren’t new. Finnair introduced Business Light in 2021, and KLM’s Business Light fare includes one checked bag compared with two on Standard, according to Cann. Travelers pay extra for food, checked bags or advanced seat selection.

Will travelers save money with basic first class?

Don’t automatically assume the basic tier means significant savings. Cann expects the cheapest business and first class fares to cost the same as before, maybe even more if travelers choose to add perks. That’s what happened in economy.

In 2017, NPR compared the basic and standard economy prices on seven routes on American Airlines, Delta and United, finding that passengers would be paying almost the same but possibly for a more inconvenient travel experience. As in, you’d pay for the seat selection but still board in the last group.

Still, there are some instances when it could be beneficial, especially if all you’re looking for is that lie-flat seat. Ultimately, it depends on dynamic pricing, routing and timing, Cann said. “Travelers can also see a real discount and a price increase on the same route.”

Is basic first class worth it?

It depends on the travel experience you’re looking for. Keep in mind, these basic first class tickets mainly offer access to the onboard experience, specifically the seat. You should also consider what else you value that costs extra, such as a second checked bag, seat selection, and lounge access. Then, it’s time to do some math, because those other privileges could add up closer to the standard fare than you’d think.

On an overnight flight, Cann said he’d compare premium economy, basic business and standard business, including the fees for what else he’d want, such as picking a seat next to his partner. For a shorter domestic flight, he would compare basic first class with an extra-legroom seat in economy.

There are situations when I think booking a basic first or business class ticket makes sense, like when traveling alone on a long-haul or red-eye flight and you’re hoping to save some money. That said, sometimes first and business class cost so much more than premium economy that I almost can’t justify it. A quick browse of flights from Los Angeles to Paris in February on United shows basic business class being about $400 less than the standard tier and more than twice the cost of premium economy. But if I’m willing to splurge, I could see myself just going for the standard ticket and getting the full experience.

For some, it’s also worth it to pay for the more expensive standard or flexible fares that allow for refunds or flight changes. “On an expensive ticket, that can matter more than any airport perk,” he said.

Kathleen Wong is a consumer travel reporter for USA TODAY. She’s the author of “The Conscious Traveller Hawai’i” and is based in Hawaii.

Reporting by Kathleen Wong, USA TODAY / USA TODAY

USA TODAY Network via Reuters Connect

 

Upgrade to an ad-free experience

As a newsletter subscriber, you're already part of the family. Members enjoy distraction-free reading, PDF downloads, and exclusive perks.

No ads • PDF downloads • 2 free eBooks • Email us questions
Learn more about membership benefits •