Market Failures Punish Honest Companies and Hurt Consumers

Photo (cc) by Oddernod

I hate when Gotcha Capitalism wins, and you do, too.

It happens all the time, because markets fail, and when they do, bad operators win and companies trying to be honest are penalized. That’s not a free market, that’s a free-for-all market. It’s terrible for everyone — consumers, businesses, the government, the economy. Terrible for everyone, that is, except the bad actor.

Let me show you what a market failure looks like, and why those of you who think government intervention is always bad are asleep at the wheel. We’re going to stick with something noncontroversial today: buying tickets to sporting events and concerts.

You know I don’t give out compliments to corporations lightly, so it should mean something when I throw flowers at StubHub for doing the right thing about two years ago when it converted to “all-in” pricing. Consumers who shopped for tickets on StubHub’s site saw the full, out-the-door price as soon as possible. No exorbitant handling fee, no $35 overnight shipping fee, no $17 print-at-home fee.

Just the price. Bravo.

And what happened? The (broken) market punished StubHub. Mercilessly. Competitors who continued hidden-fee trickery appeared to have cheaper tickets, and StubHub lost sales. Websites that sorted tickets by price punished StubHub. While survey after survey showed consumers hate the after-charge game, it’s still intoxicating. When you spend 25 minutes picking your tickets out, you can’t help but tell yourself, “Crap, I don’t feel like starting over.” And you buy the ticket. With the fees.

StubHub gamely held out, but in the end, it waved the white flag. As I like to say, you can never afford to be the only honest poker player at a game of cheats. So in September, StubHub went back into the hidden fee game. A $36 ticket on the site now costs $45. And so on.

I could have told StubHub things would have ended this way. I’ve been preaching this since my book “Gotcha Capitalism” came out and since I read Xavier Gabaix’s economics paper on “shrouded attributes” nearly a decade ago. The paper explains all the ingenious ways corporations hide, or shroud, the real price of things, and why that makes it impossible for consumers to be intelligent agents. His pet example is the computer printer. No one knows how much ink will cost, so the real cost of a printer is invisible.

And when prices are invisible, there is no free market. The entire reward system of capitalism breaks down. Instead of the best companies with the best products and lowest prices winning, the companies that shroud prices most effectively win. The cheaters win, and the honest players lose their shirts.

But that’s only half the story Gabaix tells. The other half is even more depressing, and it explains why StubHub failed (and why InterContinental Hotels failed at upfront pricing, and why JC Penney failed at “fair and square pricing,” and why Southwest Airlines keeps hinting it will have to add baggage fees).

A company might get the bright idea to shine a light on hidden fee practices of competitors, which you might think would give them a marketing win. Instead, this attempt at “debiasing,” or teaching, consumers is an abject failure. It just calls attention to the competitor’s lower prices and trains consumers that they should use competitors and try to beat them at their hidden fee game somehow.

I call this the “death of the price tag.” Here’s a link to a cute animated video I made about this problem, which is dire, and I say contributes mightily to the boom and bust cycle of American (Gotcha) Capitalism. It’s a horrible cycle. Companies cheat, they get ahead, honest companies fail, they disappear or join the dark side. Then, eventually, the gig is up, consumers do learn their lesson or the bubble of fake value pops, and all the roaches scatter with the people’s money. An entire industry collapses in on itself. Then the cycle repeats. Buy the book if you want a more intellectual discussion of this problem, or start a discussion below.But there’s a simple answer. Back to online ticket sales. There should be a rule that every actor must show the out-the-door price as soon as feasible on every site. The end. In one swift blow, that would create a fair marketplace. It would reduce friction. The right actors with the best prices would get the money. Consumers would have a better experience. Everyone wins, except the firms that existed only because they shrouded or cheated. Those firms would go out of business because what they were doing was unsustainable anyway. ( I have a story coming soon about one of those firms you won’t want to miss. In fact, I’m sure you won’t.)

Now, apply this price tag rule to other industries. Airlines. Hotels. Mortgages. Cellphones. Cars. Whenever a price is discussed, it’s the out-the-door price, not some imaginary number no one can actually buy anything for. Verizon, for example, could never again advertise smartphone plans for $80 a month when there is no actual way to get a smartphone for $80 a month (without that other $15 monthly device access fee).

Sure, go ahead, list your costs of turning on the lights or paying for plastic cups in the breakroom on some website somewhere. But the price is the price. You’d see a big change in the way consumers approach purchases. And I’m convinced you’d see an improvement in the economy as a whole.

Let me throw another flower at StubHub, which still has an option while shopping that lets you check a box that indicates “show prices with fees.” The firm is gamely trying, and I honor that.

Now, it’s time we demanded the same from all the companies we work with. But if you think there’s an industry-group, organic, market-based solution to this problem, I have a ticket to a Beatles concert to sell you. For this market failure, we need a regulator to set a clear rule. And we’ll all be better for it.

What do you think should be done about companies that mislead consumers or hide fees in the fine print? Share with us in comments below or on our Facebook page.

Disclosure: The information you read here is always objective. However, we sometimes receive compensation when you click links within our stories.

Read Next
9 Purchases That Will Make You More Productive
9 Purchases That Will Make You More Productive

These Amazon products can give you an extra edge at work and other parts of your life.

11 Expenses That Quietly Drain Your Wallet
11 Expenses That Quietly Drain Your Wallet

It’s scandalously easy to overspend in these areas of your life.

10 Ways Anyone Can Earn More Income
10 Ways Anyone Can Earn More Income

Looking for additional cash? Here are a bunch of options that are accessible to anyone with internet access.

21 Purchases You Should Never Skimp On
21 Purchases You Should Never Skimp On

With some items, it makes sense to pay a little more rather than hopping on the lowest price.

The 10 Best and 10 Worst States for Raising a Family in 2020
The 10 Best and 10 Worst States for Raising a Family in 2020

There are trade-offs no matter where you live. However, some states have big advantages when it comes to choosing a home for your family.

View this page without ads

Help us produce more money-saving articles and videos by subscribing to a membership.

Get Started

Most Popular
9 Mistakes Everyone Makes When Shopping on Amazon
9 Mistakes Everyone Makes When Shopping on Amazon

Are you losing money due to any of these missteps?

Can a Divorced Widow Claim Her First Husband’s Social Security Benefits?
Can a Divorced Widow Claim Her First Husband’s Social Security Benefits?

The rules are complicated when it comes to eligibility for survivors benefits.

Can a Twice-Divorced Woman Claim Social Security Survivors Benefits?
Can a Twice-Divorced Woman Claim Social Security Survivors Benefits?

Understanding survivors benefits rules is the key to getting the most from your benefit.

These Are the 10 Worst Cars for Depreciation
These Are the 10 Worst Cars for Depreciation

Two types of vehicles are especially likely to see steep plunges in value.

10 Things I Always Buy at Trader Joe’s
10 Things I Always Buy at Trader Joe’s

From snacks to sweets to side dishes, stock your cart with these time-tested favorites on your next TJ’s run.

9 Things You’ll Never See at Costco Again
9 Things You’ll Never See at Costco Again

The warehouse store offers an enormous selection, but these products aren’t coming back.

5 Ways Social Security Will Change in 2021
5 Ways Social Security Will Change in 2021

These adjustments will affect both workers and retirees in the new year.

11 ‘Disposable’ Items You Should Be Reusing
8 Things You Should Buy at Restaurant Supply Stores
8 Things You Should Buy at Restaurant Supply Stores

You don’t have to be a chef or a restaurant owner to shop here.

3 Ways to Get Microsoft Office for Free
3 Ways to Get Microsoft Office for Free

With a little ingenuity, you can cut Office costs to zero.

19 High-Paying Jobs You Can Get With a 2-Year Degree
19 High-Paying Jobs You Can Get With a 2-Year Degree

There are easy high-paying majors available in the U.S. — and no bachelor’s degree is required. We’re here to help you find easy degrees that pay well.

Stop Buying These 19 Things Online
Stop Buying These 19 Things Online

The internet has changed how we shop. But for some things, you’re still better off buying the old-fashioned way.

Cut These 11 Expenses Now If You Hope to Retire Early
Cut These 11 Expenses Now If You Hope to Retire Early

Like the idea of financial independence? Part of the FIRE equation is cutting costs.

27 Things You Should Never Pay For — and How to Get Them for Free
27 Things You Should Never Pay For — and How to Get Them for Free

When you know the tricks, you can save big on all kinds of useful things that others pay for.

15 Free Streaming Services to Watch While Stuck at Home
15 Free Streaming Services to Watch While Stuck at Home

These free movie streaming sites offer thousands of movies and TV shows, including recent releases and beloved classics. If you love free movies, online sites are where you need to look for the best list of features that are just one easy click away.

4 Tax Credits That Will Be More Generous in 2021
4 Tax Credits That Will Be More Generous in 2021

If you are eligible for these tax breaks, they will slash your federal income tax bill — dollar for dollar.

7 Tips for Building an Emergency Food Supply
7 Tips for Building an Emergency Food Supply

A pandemic or natural disaster could leave you reliant on your existing emergency food supply. Is your pantry well-prepared for emergencies? Knowing what to stock up on for emergencies can be a difficult task and we’re here to help.

7 Reasons to Carry Mortgage Debt Into Retirement
7 Reasons to Carry Mortgage Debt Into Retirement

It often makes financial sense to not pay off your mortgage before retiring.

These Are the 4 Best Medicare Advantage Plans for 2020
These Are the 4 Best Medicare Advantage Plans for 2020

Medicare Advantage customers themselves rate these plans highest.

View More Articles

View this page without ads

Help us produce more money-saving articles and videos by subscribing to a membership.

Get Started

Add a Comment

Our Policy: We welcome relevant and respectful comments in order to foster healthy and informative discussions. All other comments may be removed. Comments with links are automatically held for moderation.