Money Talks News may earn commission or revenue through links in the content below. Our editorial team independently selects all products. Compensation does not influence our recommendations.
You log into your 401(k) to do something boring — rebalance, bump up a contribution — and there it is: a new option to put some of your retirement money into Bitcoin, or into a private equity fund. Do you take it?
Let’s say you’re Mike, 58, and that’s exactly what you just found in your plan’s menu. It’s tempting. Everybody’s heard about someone who got rich on crypto, and “private equity” sounds like the club the wealthy get into and you don’t.
I’ve been a CPA since 1981, and a former investment advisor. I’ve watched a lot of “finally, regular people can get in” products roll out over the years. So before Mike — or you — clicks yes, let’s walk through what actually changed and what it means.
Here’s the backstory. In August 2025, President Donald Trump signed an executive order directing the Labor Department to redefine what counts as a 401(k) asset, opening the door to private equity, crypto, and real estate. (1)
The Labor Department has since drafted a rule — now in a public comment period — that shields employers from lawsuits if workers lose money on these options, with plans expected to start offering them as early as late this year or in 2027. (2)(3)
The private equity industry alone is a $5 trillion business, and it has been eager to reach the deep pool of cash sitting in America’s 401(k)s. (1) Retirement experts, meanwhile, have urged caution about pouring this much volatility into the accounts people are counting on to retire. (4)
The pitch is real. So are the catches. Here are five things to know before you opt in.
1. What actually changed — and what didn’t
The order didn’t force anything into your account. It cleared a legal path. Whether crypto or private equity shows up in your specific plan is up to your employer and the company that runs it. (3)
And the new rule’s headline feature is telling: its main job is to protect employers from being sued if these bets go bad. (2) When the fine print is mostly about who isn’t liable when you lose money, read the rest carefully.
2. “Private equity” doesn’t mean insider profits — it means higher fees
Private equity can earn strong returns, but it’s expensive. Management fees are expected to run above 2% a year, versus about 0.1% for a plain index fund. (2)
That gap sounds tiny. It isn’t. On a $200,000 balance, 2% is $4,000 a year, every year — money that comes out whether the fund wins or loses. Over a couple of decades, high fees quietly eat a shocking share of your final balance.
Quick gut-check — if your money advice is coming from random online influencers, you’re playing a dangerous game. I’ve been a CPA since 1981 and writing about money since before the internet existed. Sign up for the free Money Talks Newsletter and get expert advice that’s been tested by time.
3. The catch that bites hardest near retirement: you can’t get your money out
Private equity funds can tie your money up for years — you don’t just sell on a Tuesday and get the money the next day the way you can with a stock or a mutual fund. (2)
For a 30-year-old, that’s an annoyance. For someone Mike’s age, five to seven years from needing the money, it’s a real problem. These assets also don’t trade on an open market, so the “value” on your statement is an estimate from a model, not a price a buyer actually paid. (2)
4. If you still want in, keep it small — and get a second opinion
There’s nothing wrong with a small, speculative slice — money you can afford to watch swing wildly or even lose. The mistake is betting the retirement you’re actually counting on.
Before you move a dollar, it’s worth having someone look at your whole plan, not just the shiny new option. Get another set of expert eyes.
It’s not hard to find a fiduciary expert. For example, SmartAsset matches you free with up to three fiduciary advisors — pros legally required to put your interests first. A good one will tell you plainly whether crypto or private equity belongs anywhere near your retirement, and spot the tax and Social Security angles you can’t see alone. If you've got $100,000 or more saved, get matched with a fiduciary advisor free.
5. The boring core that usually beats the exciting bet
Here’s the unglamorous truth after decades of watching markets: the people who end up comfortable rarely got there on a hot bet. They got there by steadily owning a low-cost mix of ordinary stocks and letting it compound.
That is exactly how I did it.
If you want to build that core — or start one outside your 401(k) — you don’t need a fortune. SoFi® Active Invest lets you start with as little as $5 and no account minimums. You can buy fractional shares of companies you know and trade stocks and ETFs with no commissions, or start with a ready-made mix that spreads your money across many companies.
Fund your account with at least $50 and you can get a stock award worth $5 to $1,000. Learn more here.
INVESTMENTS ARE NOT FDIC INSURED • ARE NOT BANK GUARANTEED • MAY LOSE VALUEBrokerage and Active investing products offered through SoFi Securities LLC, member FINRA(www.finra.org)/SIPC(www.sipc.org).
The bottom line
So should Mike click yes? Maybe a sliver, if he’s the kind of person who won’t lose sleep watching it drop 40% in a month. For most people his age, the honest answer is: skip it, or keep it tiny.
The wealthy didn’t get access to private equity because it’s a secret shortcut. They got it because they could afford to lock up money for years and absorb the losses. If that’s not you, “you finally qualify” is not the same as “this is good for you.”
Your 401(k) already does the most powerful thing in finance — it lets ordinary money compound, tax-deferred, for decades. Protect that. The flashy option will always be there next year. So will the fees.
Add a Comment