10 Items Thrift Stores Wish You Wouldn’t Donate

A man drops off donations at a thrift store
366048521 / Shutterstock.com

Planning to declutter your home and donate to a thrift store? While your generosity is appreciated, some items may do more harm than good.

From unsellable goods to safety hazards, here are 10 things thrift stores wish you wouldn’t donate.

1. Broken Electronics

Shoes and broken cellphone
cunaplus / Shutterstock.com

Outdated or non-working electronics, like old TVs or appliances, are expensive to dispose of properly. Ensure items work before donating or recycle them responsibly.

If you’re upgrading your electronics, make sure you’re also saving on your phone plan to maximize your budget.

Pro Tip: Paying more than $15 a month for your cell service? Stop that. Click here to save a bundle.

2. Personal Care Products

travel size toiletries
Simone Hogan / Shutterstock.com

Opened or partially used cosmetics, lotions, and hygiene products can’t be resold due to health regulations. These items should go in the trash unless unopened and unused.

If you’re traveling and collecting hotel toiletry samples, consider donating unused products to homeless shelters instead of tossing them.

Pro Tip: Travel insurance is a must to protect that expensive vacation. Here's a list of the top travel insurers.

3. Stained or Torn Clothing

Thrift store clothing
Neil Lang / Shutterstock.com

While thrift stores welcome gently used clothes, items with stains, tears, or odors often can’t be resold.

When you’re cleaning out your closet to make way for a new wardrobe, consider sticking to donating clean, wearable garments that can truly benefit others.

Pro Tip: When shopping online, get 3-15% cash back with easy-to-use rebate services like Capital One Shopping or Rakuten.

4. Puzzles and Games With Missing Pieces

Jigsaw puzzles
Mickis-Fotowelt / Shutterstock.com

Thrift stores often can’t resell incomplete games or puzzles, as they frustrate buyers and quickly earn negative feedback. Double-check for missing parts before donating.

If you’re looking to donate, consider checking if the game or puzzle has all the pieces before dropping it off, ensuring it benefits someone else in the best way possible.

Pro Tip: Slash expenses on dining, travel, eyeglasses, prescriptions and more with AARP – Just $15/year with auto-renewal. Join now and save hundreds.

5. Damaged Furniture

Furniture and housewares for sale in a used goods or thrift store
Sussi Hj / Shutterstock.com

Furniture with stains, tears, or broken parts often ends up in the trash rather than on the sales floor. Repairing these items takes resources thrift stores typically don’t have.

Similarly, don’t waste your time or cause more wear and tear on your vehicle if it won’t benefit others

Pro Tip: Repair costs are skyrocketing. If you’re concerned about coming up with thousands for a car repair, consider the cost/benefit of an extended car warranty.

6. Used Mattresses

A couple places a mattress onto a bed frame
DGLimages / Shutterstock.com

Mattresses are a major no-go due to hygiene concerns and potential pest issues that could make others sick, including those who work in the facility or purchase such items.

Instead, look for mattress recycling programs in your area to dispose of them safely and responsibly.

Pro Tip: Life Line Screening reveals hidden risks so you can act early. Book a screening today and have peace of mind.

7. Cribs and Car Seats

Child in a car seat
Maria Sbytova / Shutterstock.com

Safety regulations for baby gear are constantly evolving, and thrift stores can’t sell items that don’t meet current standards. These donations are often discarded to avoid liability.

To future-proof your donation, make sure the items you give are up-to-date and safe for others to use.

Pro Tip: Life insurance is a must to protect your family. Here's a place to get a free, no-obligation quote.

8. Outdated Textbooks

College student in library
Jsnow my wolrd / Shutterstock.com

Most thrift stores don’t sell textbooks older than a few years. They take up valuable space and rarely find buyers. Try donating them to schools or recycling centers instead.

While you’re decluttering, consider using your free time to learn something new through audiobooks.

Pro Tip: Want to be smarter? Then use your downtime to download audiobooks with a 30-Day Free Trial. Click today for a wiser tomorrow.

9. Old Sports Equipment

FamVeld / Shutterstock.com

Outdated or heavily worn sports gear often doesn’t sell, especially if it’s missing parts or no longer safe to use. Look for specialty recycling programs instead.

When you’re looking to upgrade or purchase new sporting equipment, consider trading in your old gear for store credit or discounts at sports trade-in stores to make your new purchase more affordable, giving you a cost-effective way to upgrade your gear.

Pro Tip: Boost your shopping power: Get a rare card with 0% intro APR to ease debt pressure and up to 10% cash back in your first year! Save more, earn more, and take control of your finances today.

10. Holiday Decorations Out of Season

Christmas decorations at Costco
Annie0303 / Shutterstock.com

While holiday décor can be popular during the right season, donating off-season items can clog up storage space.

Time your donations wisely for better chances of resale, and consider holding off until the next season to donate for maximum value. This helps thrift stores keep their shelves stocked with items that will sell quickly.

Donate Wisely, Support Thrift Stores

woman decluttering clothes
Andrey_Popov / Shutterstock.com

Thoughtful donations ensure your items benefit both the store and the community. When in doubt, check with your local thrift store about what they accept.

By donating responsibly, you’ll make a positive impact!

 

Upgrade to an ad-free experience

As a newsletter subscriber, you're already part of the family. Members enjoy distraction-free reading, PDF downloads, and exclusive perks.

No ads • PDF downloads • 2 free eBooks • Email us questions
Learn more about membership benefits •