10 Tips for Giving Preloved Items as Thoughtful Gifts

Woman holding a gift
Artem Onoprienko / Shutterstock.com

Editor's Note: This story originally appeared on Living on the Cheap.

Is it okay to give used items as gifts? Absolutely! The idea of gifting previously loved items is becoming increasingly popular — and for good reasons. Not only does it add a personal touch that brand-new gifts often lack, but it also supports sustainability by reducing waste.

Whether it’s that quirky vintage lamp from your favorite thrift shop or a classic novel with beautifully worn pages, these gifts come with a story and charm that simply can’t be bought off the shelf.

By choosing to give used items, you’re gifting with intention and contributing to a more sustainable world. Curious to explore this gifting trend further? Let’s dive in!

If you’re wondering if regifting a gift is okay, or whether buying a friend a used gift is taboo, these tips can help.

Is it rude to give someone a used gift?

Man in thrift store
SpeedKingz / Shutterstock.com

Not necessarily. It can actually be a delightful surprise, showing thoughtfulness and care.

Imagine gifting a vintage book to a literature lover or a cherished family heirloom to a relative. These used gifts carry stories and sentimental value that new items simply cannot match.

Of course, always consider the recipient’s tastes and the condition of the gift. Clean it up, wrap it with love, and include a note! Above all, be sure they’ll appreciate your gesture.

I have given and received used presents. (I actually refer to this as preloved gifting!)

When it comes to gifting used items, there are a few tips to keep in mind.

1. Choose thoughtfully

Woman shopping for secondhand furniture at a thrift store
Iakov Filimonov / Shutterstock.com

Select items that have meaning or relevance to the recipient. Consider their interests, hobbies, or needs.

For example, a used cookbook from a favorite chef could be perfect for a food lover.

2. Ensure quality

Woman cleaning an antique
aerogondo2 / Shutterstock.com

Inspect items carefully to make sure they are in good condition. Clean and repair them if needed. A gently used item that looks new will be more appreciated.

3. Add a personal touch

Women exchanging gifts
dodotone / Shutterstock.com

Personalize the gift to make it unique. You could write a heartfelt note explaining why you chose this item or include a story about its history.

4. Creative presentation

gift box with crafted gift tag
ouh_desire / Shutterstock.com

Present the gift in a creative way. Use attractive wrapping paper or a vintage box.

Adding small details like a ribbon or handmade tag can enhance the presentation.

5. Communicate the value

Friends exchanging gifts at a holiday party
Ground Picture / Shutterstock.com

Explain the significance of the gift.

You might say something like, “I found this book and thought it perfectly aligns with your love for history.” This helps the recipient understand the thought behind the gift.

6. Highlight environmental benefits

Son giving a Father's Day gift to his dad
Prostock-studio / Shutterstock.com

Share the eco-friendly aspect of giving used items. Mention that reusing and recycling help reduce waste, making your gift both thoughtful and sustainable.

7. Consider the occasion

Child giving his father a gift
wavebreakmedia / Shutterstock.com

Tailor your gift to fit the occasion. If it’s a birthday, think about what the person has been talking about recently. For a holiday, find something festive or sentimental.

8. Be honest and open

Older women exchanging gifts
CGN089 / Shutterstock.com

If appropriate, be candid about the item’s pre-loved status. Some recipients appreciate knowing they’re getting an item with a history.

9. Add complementary items

Tattooed hands holding a gift box
Syda Productions / Shutterstock.com

Pair the main item with a small, new accessory. For example, if you’re gifting a used teapot, include a box of tea to complete the gift.

10. Share a story

Man giving a gift to his mother
Happy Together / Shutterstock.com

If the item has a known history or personal significance, share this story. It can make the gift all the more meaningful and cherished.

By following these tips, you can give gifts with personality and thoughtfulness while promoting sustainability and creativity.

Now, here are a few rules for shopping for gifts at consignment stores.

You want the gift to be new

Thrift store decorating
Iryna Mylinska / Shutterstock.com

Or you want it to at least appear new. Start by shopping in stores with a good reputation for consigning designer brands and insisting that clothing items are in good shape (i.e., freshly laundered, no stains or rips, no missing buttons).

Chances are good many of the wardrobe pieces on these racks will still have their original tags attached. It doesn’t excuse you from doing a thorough once-over, but it does increase the odds that what looks perfect will, indeed, be perfect.

You want the gift to fit

Woman shopping in a thrift store
SpeedKingz / Shutterstock.com

Most consignment stores have a no-return policy, darn your luck. This is why I browse the racks for items that don’t need an exact size.

Blazers, for instance, can be a size or two off and still fit. Same with a sweater. A blouse or dress is getting riskier, and pants or shoes are a no-no.

Pay attention to the entire store

Furniture and housewares for sale in a used goods or thrift store
Sussi Hj / Shutterstock.com

Many consignment stores today sell more than used items. For instance, my favorite clothing shop brings in new, novelty items like scarves, a purse decoration that doubles as a glasses/iPhone microfiber cloth, leggings and a fun jewelry collection.

All these items are new but priced less than they would be at a department store.

Is regifting gifts acceptable?

Guest couple arriving at a house with wine
Jacob Lund / Shutterstock.com

Why not? You can buy a new secondhand gift, or regift one of your gifts that you’ve gotten over the years. Why let a present go to waste when you can share it with others?

Wine and candles just so happen to be regifted all the time!

 

Upgrade to an ad-free experience

As a newsletter subscriber, you're already part of the family. Members enjoy distraction-free reading, PDF downloads, and exclusive perks.

No ads PDF downloads 2 free eBooks Email us questions
Learn more about membership benefits