Vanguard just dropped its big annual retirement report, and the headline number is a beauty: the average 401(k) balance hit a record $167,970. Cue the celebration, right?
Hold on.
I’ve been a CPA since 1981, and I’ve watched “record retirement savings!” headlines roll out for 45 years. They almost always hide the part that actually matters. This one’s no different.
1. The record is real — but averages lie
First, the good news, because it’s real. Vanguard’s average 401(k) balance jumped 13% last year to $167,970. A booming stock market did most of the heavy lifting. If your account had a great year, congratulations — you earned it.
But an average is a slippery thing.
Picture a room with nine people who have $30,000 saved and one who has $3 million. The “average” is over $300,000. Nobody in that room is living like it. That’s exactly what’s happening with this number.
2. The typical saver has $44,115 — about $147 a month
Here’s the figure Vanguard tucks below the headline: the median balance is $44,115. Median means the person dead center — half of savers have more, half have less. That’s your real “typical” worker.
So where do you really stand? If your 401(k) is anywhere near $44,115, you’re not behind — you’re average. Half the country has less.
Run that median through the standard 4% withdrawal rule and you get about $1,765 a year. That’s roughly $147 a month.
Try funding a retirement on $147 a month. You can’t.
Want it broken down by age? Here’s how the typical balance shifts decade by decade.
3. Hardship withdrawals just hit a record, too
While balances climbed, so did desperation. Vanguard says 6% of participants took a hardship withdrawal in 2025 — the highest share on record, up from 5% the year before. It’s the sixth straight annual increase, and roughly triple the pre-pandemic rate.
The median withdrawal? About $1,900.
That’s not someone cashing out for a boat. That’s more likely someone covering rent or a medical bill.
Quick gut-check — if your money advice is coming from random online influencers, you’re playing a dangerous game. I’ve been a CPA since 1981 and writing about money since before the internet existed. Sign up for the free Money Talks Newsletter and get expert advice that’s been tested by time.
4. The people raiding their accounts can least afford to
Dig into who’s pulling money out, and it gets bleaker. Workers earning under $100,000 a year are about 3.5 times more likely to take a hardship withdrawal than higher earners.
And roughly 7 in 10 of those withdrawals go toward stopping an eviction or foreclosure, or covering a medical emergency.
These aren’t bad savers. They’re people out of options.
5. This isn’t a willpower problem — it’s a design problem
Here’s what the finger-waggers miss. Vanguard’s own 25 years of data show the single biggest driver of whether you save isn’t discipline. It’s whether your employer automatically enrolls you.
When workers get defaulted into a plan, they save and they stay invested. Participation has climbed to a record 86%. The Investment Company Institute found nearly half of 401(k) holders say they probably wouldn’t save at all without one.
So the problem isn’t that Americans are lazy with money. It’s that millions still have no plan at work to be defaulted into.
So what should you do?
You can’t rewrite the retirement system by yourself. But you’re not helpless, either.
If you’ve got a plan at work, grab every dollar of employer match — that’s free money you’ll never see again if you skip it. Bump your contribution 1% a year, and you’ll barely feel it.
And know your own number, because the average tells you nothing about you. If you’re behind, you’ve got more company than you think — and more options than you fear.
Just be careful where you get your guidance, because some sources are far better than others.
The record headline isn’t the story. The $147 a month is. Plan around the real number — not the one designed to make you feel fine.
Add a Comment