Watchdog Says Amazon Black Friday Sales Aren’t Real Deals

GPT Image / OpenAI

Customers flock to Amazon on Black Friday and Cyber Monday sales events looking for deals.

What they often find, according to a consumer watchdog report, are prices that were the same or lower before the sale.

A new report from Groundwork Collaborative, a progressive thinktank, examined more than 350 Black Friday and Cyber Monday deals Amazon listed in 2024 and 2025.

Nearly 1 in 3 of those deals offered no actual savings, the report found. Prices for 29% of items were the same or lower in the month leading up to Black Friday or Cyber Monday. More than half of the items had the same or lower prices in the 90 days before the sales event.

“Americans are really squeezed right now, and they are waiting to do their holiday shopping at these major sales events because they believe that these major sales events offer real savings and a real deal,” said Lindsay Owens, CEO of Groundwork Collaborative, in an interview.

Owens said the report shows that “waiting till Black Friday, waiting for Cyber Monday, may not be all it’s cracked up to be.”

But Amazon pushed back hard against the report, questioning the findings and faulting the data.

In a Nov. 13 letter to Owens and colleagues, an Amazon executive wrote that “it appears Groundwork has limited interest in the facts and is focusing on pursuing a pre-determined narrative.”

Amazon sits at the center of Cyber Week, the span from Thanksgiving to Cyber Monday that more or less kicks off the holiday shopping season. Cyber Week delivered $44 billion in online sales in 2025, according to Adobe.

Amazon reaps more than one-third of all U.S. e-commerce sales, according to Marketplace Pulse. The retailer runs several big sale events every year and staged a 12-day Black Friday sale in 2025, the report says.

Amazon Says the Think Tank’s Report Is ‘Deeply Flawed’

The retailer responded to the study with a Nov. 16 statement on its website, which said the think tank had “published deeply flawed and false claims” about the retailer’s holiday sales, based on “flawed methodology and inaccurate data.”

Amazon said the watchdog report unfairly cherrypicked 350 items from among more than 10 million “deals” offered in the two holiday events. The retailer said the think tank included products that weren’t actually on sale and cited prices higher than what customers actually paid.

Amazon said its own research found that 98% of the products included in the Groundwork report went on sale at prices equal to or lower than pre-sale prices. The retailer noted that consumers can use Amazon’s AI shopping assistant to track the price history on any item.

Much of the dispute between the retailer and the watchdog group centered on data from another Amazon sale, Prime Day 2026, that was ultimately removed from the Groundwork report. Amazon said it “strengthened” its sales-event “guardrails” in 2026 so advertised deals almost always represented lower prices.

Amazon said Groundwork removed the 2026 data from its report because it didn’t fit the group’s foregone conclusions. Groundwork said it removed the data because Prime Day is limited to Prime members, while the other holiday sales are not.

The Washington, D.C. think tank stood by its findings, casting itself as the underdog in a David-vs-Goliath dispute against one of the largest corporations in the world.

“We’re a small team,” Owens said. “We spent a year on this. We’re very confident of the results.”

Groundwork said Amazon failed to identify any specific inaccuracies among the sale items included in the report.

Amazon’s Online Sales Events Have Faced Criticism Before

Many retailers routinely raise prices in advance of big sales and then lower them again to create the impression consumers are getting a deal.

A British consumer group tracked prices for 175 items across eight retailers, including Amazon, in 2024 and 2025 and found that none were at their lowest price on Black Friday, according to The Guardian.

In the autumn of 2025, a Washington Post columnist examined nearly 50 Amazon products he had bought in the months before a Prime Days event, held in October, and found that he would have saved only 0.6% if he had bought them “on sale.”

Social media brims with anecdotal accounts of Amazon touting dubious sales on Prime Day, Black Friday and Cyber Monday.

The Groundwork Collaborative report examined a broader list of items, pulled from Amazon’s own Black Friday and Cyber Monday deals pages. The retailer tells customers those deals are “handpicked” and represent some of the best discounts consumers can find, the report says.

Shoppers who visit Amazon during a sale event will “often see a struck-through price, a bright red discount badge, and a promise of big savings,” the report says. In this era of elevated inflation, consumers look to sales to offset rising prices.

Report Says Some Holiday ‘Sale’ Prices Were Actually Higher

But Groundwork found that nearly 1 in 10 of the products it tracked had lower prices in the month before the sales event, and 27% had lower prices in the previous 90 days.

A few examples:

An Apple Watch Series 10, listed on sale for $679.99 on Black Friday 2025, had been priced at $602 a few weeks earlier.

A pair of men’s UGG Butte boots, on sale for $179.98 on Cyber Monday 2025, had cost $98.40 in the prior month.

As a potential solution, Groundwork proposes that policymakers should require Amazon and other retailers to state the lowest listed price for an item in the 30 days before an advertised sale, rather than a purported “list price” or “typical price.”

“It’s just really frustrating that Amazon has the faith of the American consumer and is really flouting it with these false deals,” Owens said.

Reporting by Daniel de Visé, USA TODAY / USA TODAY

USA TODAY Network via Reuters Connect

 

Upgrade to an ad-free experience

As a newsletter subscriber, you're already part of the family. Members enjoy distraction-free reading, PDF downloads, and exclusive perks.

No ads • PDF downloads • 2 free eBooks • Email us questions
Learn more about membership benefits •