Personal finance advisor, agent, broker, coach, counselor, representative, robo-advisor: the titles blur together.
How do you know what kind of finance professional you need to help you file taxes, build wealth, plan for the future or manage your retirement accounts?
It helps to understand what each does.
If you have over $100,000 in savings, get advice from a credentialed pro. SmartAsset offers a free service that matches you to a vetted, fiduciary advisor, bound to act in your best interest.
CFP and RIA
These signal real training and a fiduciary duty to put your interests first. Whether someone is a fiduciary is one of the most important things to establish about anyone advising you.
Certified financial planner (CFP)
A certification awarded by the CFP Board after requirements in education, examination, experience and ethics, covering investments, insurance, taxes, retirement and estate strategy. CFP professionals commit to act as a fiduciary at all times when giving financial advice.
The limit: The Board is a certifying body, not a regulator, so its ultimate penalty is stripping the credential rather than a legal sanction.
Registered investment advisor (RIA)
A firm or person registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) or a state. Larger advisors generally register with the SEC, smaller ones with the states.
RIAs owe clients a fiduciary duty under the Investment Advisers Act of 1940, meaning they must put your interests ahead of their own, and they file a disclosure document called Form ADV that you can look up on the SEC’s public database before hiring them.
One wrinkle: The RIA is usually the firm, while the person advising you may be an investment advisor representative, or IAR, registered to give advice on the firm’s behalf.
CFA, broker or registered representative, insurance agent
Each carries a real license, registration or credential, but not an ongoing duty to act in your best interest. Some have excellent reputations and provide excellent service, so a personal recommendation you trust matters more here.
Chartered financial analyst (CFA)
This is the heavyweight credential for investment analysis, granted by the CFA Institute after three levels of demanding exams plus work experience. Charterholders concentrate in portfolio management, research and asset management, more often for funds and institutions than individual households.
A CFA can offer deep expertise on how a portfolio is built, but this is not a title built around a personal advice relationship.
Broker or registered representative
Registered through the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority to sell securities. Brokers answer to the SEC’s Regulation Best Interest, which requires acting in your best interest on a recommendation but stops short of the ongoing duty an RIA owes.
Watch for dual registration as both broker and advisor, which lets the standard shift depending on the transaction, sometimes in the same meeting.
Insurance agent
Sells protection such as life insurance, long-term care coverage, annuities. The distinction that affects you is captive, selling one company’s lineup, versus independent, shopping multiple carriers.
Either way, agents typically earn a commission on what they sell, worth remembering when an annuity is pitched as the answer to a question a fee-only advisor might solve differently.
Financial planner, advisor, wealth manager
These titles alone do not guarantee a particular credential. Someone using one may hold a CFP and a fiduciary duty, or neither, so the words alone tell you little about training or a duty to you. Make anyone using one tell you which of the credentials and standards above sits underneath it.
CPA, EA, estate planning attorney, financial coach, credit counselor, robo-advisor
These promise real expertise for a defined task, where the fiduciary question works differently or does not apply.
Certified public accountant (CPA) and enrolled agent (EA)
Both CPAs and EAs handle taxes and both hold unlimited rights to represent you before the IRS. A CPA is credentialed by a state board of accountancy and trained broadly across accounting, auditing and tax, and only a CPA can perform certain services like audits; an EA is licensed federally by the IRS and specializes purely in tax.
Some CPAs add a personal financial specialist (PFS) credential to move into planning. Note that “tax preparer” on its own signals no particular professional credential.
Estate planning attorney
Drafts the documents that lay out what happens to your money and property, and who speaks for you if you cannot: wills, trusts, powers of attorney and health care directives. These are legal instruments, so this is a job for a licensed attorney, though the good ones coordinate with your other pros.
Financial coach and credit counselor
Behavior rather than investments. A coach helps you build spending habits, kill debt and get organized, and the title is unregulated, so credentials vary. Nonprofit credit counselors help you tackle debt and can set up a debt management plan.
Both tend to cost far less than an advisor, a sensible first stop when the problem is cash flow rather than a portfolio.
Robo-advisor
This is software, not a person. An algorithm builds and rebalances a portfolio of low-cost funds for a fraction of a human advisor’s fee. The trade-off is judgment: No one is there to talk you off a ledge in a crash. Many are registered as RIAs, and firms increasingly offer hybrid versions pairing the algorithm with a human advisor for a higher fee.
Follow the money, not the title
Before trusting your money to anyone, ask three questions.
- What training stands behind the name? Is it just a title, or have they earned credentials?
- Is this person a fiduciary every time they advise me? That is, do they act in your best interest, regardless of what they earn, every time?
- How are they paid? Fee-only means paid only by you. Fee-based means client fees plus commissions from products they sell. Commission-only means paid entirely by what they sell you. None of that makes a commissioned pro dishonest, but it points to where the incentives run, and that is the one thing an impressive title will never tell you.
The professional who welcomes those questions is usually the one worth hiring.
It takes around 10 minutes to find your fiduciary with SmartAsset's free service for investors with at least $100,000. Start now.
Add a Comment