Following record investment in the technology, artificial intelligence is reshaping the American workplace, from automated meeting summaries to assistance with radiology diagnostics. But the massive productivity boom that Silicon Valley executives promised would result from the AI buildout remains to be seen.
In past technological revolutions, productivity spikes often took years or decades to translate into broadly higher worker pay. In recent years, worker compensation has generally grown slower than productivity growth. Still, Amazon CEO Jeff Bezos told Fox News that AI-driven productivity could eventually allow people to support families on shorter workweeks or single incomes, while xAI CEO – and the world’s richest person – Elon Musk believes that technological progress could eventually make traditional employment optional.
“My prediction is that work will be optional. It’ll be like playing sports or a video game or something like that,” Musk said late last year. “Assuming there is a continued improvement in AI and robotics, which seems likely, money will stop being relevant in the future.”
To experts, that future seems farfetched, and it hasn’t arrived yet. In fact, risks are more evident than the rosy future envisioned by AI’s champions, according to some studying the field. AI’s effects on aggregate productivity growth “appear to be small so far,” Federal Reserve economists said in a November paper.
Americans have a less optimistic view of AI than Musk does. Nearly half of U.S. adults polled earlier this year thought the technology would replace workers, and many blame the AI buildout for pushing up some select costs. The midterm elections appeared a strong rebuke as voters approved bans on data centers and elected politicians who campaigned on halting their construction.
Although investment related to the technology is helping drive U.S. economic growth, experts who responded to a Fed survey released Nov. 13 said AI poses a greater risk to the financial system than anything else. Meanwhile, markets are experiencing volatility as investors react to an Nvidia scandal and wait for Anthropic to go public.
As monetary policymakers attempt to make sense of AI’s effect on the economy, these topics and more were the subject of debate at the Fed’s Productivity and Jobs Task Force Conference in San Francisco on Nov. 16.
“My Fed colleagues and I are not at this conference as futurists to speculate on each new turn technology might take,” Fed Chair Kevin Warsh said in prepared remarks. “Our job is to prepare for whatever comes next. That means contingency planning, which becomes only more important when the world is changing this fast.”
How Is Productivity Measured?
When Americans think about productivity, they may consider how many items they managed to cross off their to-do list in an afternoon. When economists think about productivity, they often examine output produced per hour for all workers.
While it excludes several components of the economy, the Bureau of Labor Statistics’ measure of nonfarm business labor productivity is considered one of the primary ways to estimate productivity. Since the agency began keeping track in 1947, its long-term growth rate has been 2.2% per year, according to the BLS.
It surpassed expectations in the third quarter this year, rising 3.6% from the second quarter, according to the department’s data. But over the year, it was up 2.1%, slightly lower than the historical average and not necessarily a “booming” rate, according to Ricardo Marto, an economist at the St. Louis Fed.
“There is again a bit of an increase in productivity. Can we say it’s going to be a long-lasting boom? It’s early,” Marto said. “I’m optimistic, not as optimistic as the tech CEOs.”
How Has AI Affected Productivity So Far?
Productivity growth has ticked up in recent years. Labor productivity has grown at an average annual rate of 2.2% in the current business cycle, up from 1.5% in the previous cycle. However, economists say it is probably too soon to credit AI for the increase.
“This surge in productivity began before the debut of popular AI chatbots in 2022 and likely reflects a variety of factors, including a pickup in new business formation,” Philip Jefferson, vice chair of the Fed’s Board of Governors, said during a Nov. 13 speech in San Diego.
A November report from the Bank of England found that AI had increased U.K. productivity by around 0.5% over the past three years, or about 0.1 to 0.2 percentage points added to annual productivity growth since early 2024 – a “modest” rise.
Still, there are some signs that AI is already affecting early-career workers and people in certain specialized roles in the United States, but much of the disruption is likely still to come, Fed economists said in the November paper.
“Productivity growth may further increase over the next several years as data center buildout continues and workers and firms learn to make more effective use of the technology,” they wrote.
What Would an AI-Driven Productivity Boom Mean for Workers?
Executives, economists and academics theorize that AI, like past technological innovations, will eventually lead to the creation of new jobs, but that it may also make some roles obsolete.
Unemployment rose about one percentage point more in the most AI-exposed jobs compared to the least-exposed jobs since late 2022, according to Cleveland Fed research. It also found that younger workers faced a tougher time getting hired, perhaps as companies considered that AI may make their employees more productive and hesitated to increase headcounts. The unemployment rate for 23- to 30-year-olds is up two percentage points since 2022.
“For many workers already inside these occupations, this may feel like business as usual. For those on the outside trying to get in – particularly younger workers entering the labor market for the first time – the door appears to be harder to open,” the researchers said.
For the employed, AI may increase their productivity in a variety of ways. Eugenio Aleman, Raymond James’ chief economist, said AI has cut down the time he spends building economic models and made his work “much easier.”
He added that productivity may increase not just because AI will help workers be more efficient, but also because Americans worried about losing their jobs might work harder.
“If you look at the data on productivity during the pandemic, productivity skyrockets,” Aleman said. “Why? Because so many workers lost their jobs, and those who remained in the labor force had to work harder.”
Would More Productivity Make Life More Affordable?
Economic theory says wages improve as productivity increases, but that’s not happening yet, Aleman said.
“This is a stage with corporations or companies holding increases in wages in order to invest more into the new technologies,” he added. “But as soon as these new technologies are embedded in the production process, I think that workers are going to start claiming their own share.”
In the short term, the data center buildout is pushing up electricity costs and demand for products like memory chips, which has translated into price pressure on some consumer electronics.
“Over the medium term, the supply of these goods should catch up, and the broader boost to aggregate productivity from adoption should materialize,” Jefferson said. “Both of those developments should ease the upward pressure on prices we see today.”
Still, Americans will most likely have to work to earn a living.
“We might all be richer, and that’s good. That doesn’t mean we’ll stay home and stay on the couch,” Marto said. “We’ll buy new products that have yet to be invented. … But I don’t think it’s in the cards just to stop working.”
Reach economy reporter Rachel Barber at [email protected]. Follow her on X @rachelbarber_ and on LinkedIn.
Reporting by Rachel Barber, USA TODAY / USA TODAY. USA TODAY Network via Reuters Connect.

Add a Comment